Airlines that once flew through selected airspace corridors to avoid Ukraine’s civil war are adjusting routes or staying away from the country entirely after a Malaysian Air passenger jet was shot down.
Malaysian Air said all its European flights will take alternative routes immediately after its Boeing Co. (BA:US) 777 crashed yesterday, killing all 298 people onboard. Deutsche Lufthansa AG (LHA) and KLM said they will avoid flying over eastern Ukraine, while Delta Air Lines Inc. (DAL:US) is staying away from the whole country.
Carriers from the U.S. to Europe are reassessing their routes over the region after Flight 17 was shot down in an area that has been the main battleground involving Russian control over parts of Ukraine. Air traffic control and airlines should have been more cautious of the area, said Brent Spencer of Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University.
“The fact that the airspace is not restricted doesn’t mean you don’t need to give extra consideration whether you want to fly to it or not,” said Spencer, who is director of Embry-Riddle’s air-traffic control program in Prescott, Arizona. “You might want to think twice about flying through an airspace where there’s somebody shooting missiles at anybody.”
U.S. carriers have voluntarily agreed not operate in the airspace near the Russian-Ukraine border, the Federal Aviation Administration said in an e-mail. Italy’s aviation agency ENAC said its airlines should avoid flying over the area as well.
The area was a popular route for flights going between Europe and Asian cities such as Singapore, Mikael Robertsson, co-founder of Stockholm-based Flightradar24 AB, said in an interview. The Malaysian Air flight was en route to Kuala Lumpur from Amsterdam when it went down near the eastern town of Torez.
The airspace over the region was closed to air traffic up to 32,000 feet (9,750 meters), according to Eurocontrol, an international organization which coordinates European air traffic agencies. The Malaysian Air flight was flying 1,000 feet above the restricted space.
The Ukrainian government in Kiev has said the plane was shot down by pro-Russian rebels. The separatists denied the accusation.
Delta, the third-largest U.S. carrier, is going to avoid all Ukrainian airspace “out of an abundance of caution,” according to a statement on the Atlanta-based company’s website.
The region wasn’t subject to any alerts to pilots, known as notices to airmen, said Perry Flint, a spokesman for the International Air Transport Association in Washington.
The U.S. FAA had barred U.S. airlines from flying over southern areas of Ukraine in a notice issued April 3, after Russia annexed the region of Crimea. That notice didn’t cover the area where the Malaysian plane crashed.
The FAA had issued the restriction because Russia had attempted to assert control over flights above Crimea, which the U.S. considered “unilateral and illegal,” according to an e-mail yesterday from the agency. Flights by U.S. carriers were steered away because of the potential for conflicting instructions by controllers from Russia and Ukraine, according to the statement.
Prior to the turmoil in the Ukraine, there were about 300 to 400 flights a day that flew over the region, Robertsson said. In recent months, there have been about 100 a day, he said.
Within a short time of the crash, the flight routes were emptied of international flights, he said.
Lufthansa, which has its main hub in Frankfurt, is diverting flights, according to a spokesman, Thomas Janchow. KLM, whose booking codes were shared on Malaysian Air Flight 17, said “as a precautionary measure KLM avoids flying over the concerned territory,” according to the Dutch carrier, a unit of Air France-KLM Group.
“With immediate effect, all European flights operated by Malaysia Airlines will be taking alternative routes avoiding the usual route,” the airline said today in a statement. “The usual flight route was earlier declared safe by the International Civil Aviation Organisation.”
The International Air Transportation Association has said the airspace the plane flew through was not subject to restrictions, Malaysian Air said.
The European Cockpit Association, a pilot group, said by e-mail that the Malaysian plane’s path was “the most common route for flights from Europe to South East Asia.” British Airways said its flights don’t traverse eastern Ukraine, though the company is putting its daily London-Kiev route under review.
Josh Freed, a spokesman for American Airlines Group Inc., said the world’s largest carrier was checking on whether any of its planes fly in the area. United Continental Holdings Inc. (UAL:US), the second-biggest airline, doesn’t fly through Ukrainian airspace.
Airlines have been paring service to Ukraine, with Lufthansa halting flights to Donetsk as tension escalated between the government and separatist rebels. Emirates, the biggest carrier by international traffic, said this month that it would suspend its flight linking Dubai and Kiev from Aug. 1, citing political uncertainty.
To contact the reporters on this story: Richard Weiss in Frankfurt at firstname.lastname@example.org; Michael Sasso in Atlanta at email@example.com
To contact the editors responsible for this story: Romaine Bostick at firstname.lastname@example.org Elizabeth Wasserman, Rosalind Mathieson