Samuel and Charles Wyly used a web of offshore trusts to illegally hide their stock holdings and evade trading limits, a jury found, leaving Samuel Wyly and his brother’s estate potentially liable for as much as $550 million.
The panel of eight women and four men today delivered the verdict in Manhattan federal court in favor of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. The regulator claimed the brothers, founders of Michaels Stores Inc., hid ownership of shares of companies on whose boards they sat and broke disclosure regulations by failing to reveal the full extent of their offshore holdings.
“We will continue to fight for justice through the next phases of the legal process,” Stephen Susman, their lawyer, said in a statement after the verdict. “We maintain that Sam and Charles Wyly acted in good faith.”
The verdict, delivered after two and a half days of deliberations, is the latest trial win by the SEC in the Manhattan courthouse. A jury in August found former Goldman Sachs Group Inc. vice president Fabrice Tourre liable for his role in structuring a failed $1 billion investment. The regulator brings few cases to trial and it took more than a decade to do so with the Wylys -- so long that Charles died leaving his estate as a defendant.
Samuel Wyly, who testified in his own defense during the trial, did himself little good, according to one of the jurors, retired letter carrier Kevin Rothman. Wyly “maybe wasn’t all that sharp” on the stand, he said.
“They felt they would put him on the stand because this was his case,” one of Wyly’s lawyers told the jurors in a closed-door session after the verdict, according to Rothman. “This was his ballgame.”
Rothman said one of the women jurors was “a little bit of a holdout” against a verdict for the SEC. The juror was persuaded after about a day and a half, he said.
Jurors found in favor of the SEC on all nine of its claims against the Wylys.
The SEC seeks to impose penalties and force Samuel Wyly, 79, and the estate of his brother, to turn over $550 million of allegedly illegal gains. U.S. District Judge Shira Scheindlin, who oversaw the trial, will determine whether the Wylys committed insider trading after hearing arguments from both sides. Scheindlin set Aug. 4 for the start of a three-day trial to determine also how much the Wylys will have to pay.
The SEC, among its claims, alleged the Wylys made $31.7 million by using inside information they gained from sitting on the board of Sterling Software Inc. to accumulate shares in 1999, ahead of the company’s $4 billion sale to Computer Associates International Inc. (CA:US)
The Wylys claimed they used the offshore trusts for tax purposes, estate planning and asset protection. They said they never concealed the offshore trusts and relied on the advice of “an army of lawyers” they trusted to ensure they complied with the law.
During the trial, SEC lawyers presented witnesses, including Michael French, the Wylys’ former lawyer who settled with the regulator before the trial. Several testified that the Wylys exercised control over the offshore trusts through trustees who always complied with their orders.
“We will continue to hold accountable, and bring to trial when necessary, those who commit fraud no matter how complex their scheme or how hard they try to hide it,” Andrew Ceresney, the SEC’s enforcement director, said in a statement following today’s verdict.
In his testimony, Samuel Wyly insisted that he had not violated federal securities laws and said trustees on the Isle of Man had acted independently, approving transactions without his direction.
Charles Wyly died in August 2011 when his 1983 Porsche Targa was hit by another vehicle near Aspen, Colorado.
The case is SEC v. Wyly, 10-cv-05760, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York (Manhattan).
To contact the reporters on this story: Bob Van Voris in federal court in Manhattan at email@example.com; Patricia Hurtado in Federal Court in Manhattan at
To contact the editors responsible for this story: David E. Rovella at firstname.lastname@example.org; Joe Schneider at email@example.com Joe Schneider, Andrew Dunn