Tim Hortons Inc. (THI) investors are betting Highfields Capital Management LP will spark an extended rally as the hedge fund demands higher payouts and an end to a struggling U.S. expansion at Canada’s largest coffee and doughnuts chain.
Shares of the Oakville, Ontario-based company have surged 7.4 percent to C$58.64 since Boston-based Highfields said May 1 it had increased its stake to 4 percent and met with the company to recommend using debt to fund “capital return” and halting a push into the U.S. The stock had been the third-worst performing among 16 global restaurant companies on a one-year basis through April, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
“Even if they only get half of what they’re proposing done, the change that would drive in terms of how they think about the business and how they manage the business would be pretty material,” Kenric Tyghe, an analyst with Raymond James Securities said by phone from Toronto yesterday.
While Tim Hortons, founded by a National Hockey League player of the same name in 1964, says it sells eight out of 10 cups of coffee in Canada from 3,436 restaurants, the brand has been slow to catch on in the U.S. Operating profit last year was C$182,000 ($181,180) per store in Canada compared with C$20,000 per store in the U.S., Derek Dley, an analyst at Canaccord Genuity Corp. said in an e-mail yesterday.
Tim Hortons, which reported first-quarter revenue and net income below analysts’ estimates today, had lost 4.3 percent in the 12 months before Highfields made a letter to management public on May 1. Revenue rose 1.4 percent to C$731.5 million, compared with the average estimate of C$748.9 million. Net income fell 2.9 percent to C$86.2 million, or 56 cents a share, compared with estimates of 61 cents.
The stock has risen 79 percent in the five years through yesterday, compared with a 13 percent drop in the broad Standard & Poor’s/TSX Composite index.
The company today appointed Marc Caira, 59, a former executive with Nestle SA (NESN) as its new president and chief executive officer. Paul House had been acting CEO since May 2011. The company will hold its annual shareholders’ meeting tomorrow.
By increasing leverage and cutting back or stopping investment in its U.S. business, Tim Hortons’ shares could approach or exceed C$100 within 12 to 18 months, Highfields said in a letter to Tim Hortons’ management. Earnings growth “would be achieved by reducing the equity base through capital return as opposed to investing capital into the U.S. at sub-par returns,” said the letter, which Highfields provided to Bloomberg.
Molly Morse, a Highfields spokeswoman, declined to comment further. Highfields, founded in 1998, manages $11 billion and does not make performance figures public, Morse said.
Tim Hortons should emulate rivals Dunkin’ Brands Group Inc. (DNKN:US) and Domino’s Pizza Inc. (DPZ:US) by taking advantage of record low borrowing rates to drive growth, said Highfields in the letter.
The company’s ratio of net debt to earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, or EBITDA, is 0.56 times, below the average 1.1 times of its restaurant peers, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Dunkin’ Brands and Domino’s have the highest ratios at 5.1 times and 4.7 times respectively.
“We do not see any structural reason why THI couldn’t increase its debt leverage and return the cash back to shareholders, if it chose to do so,” Michael Kelter, an analyst at Goldman Sachs, wrote in a research note to clients May 1, referring to Tim Hortons by its stock ticker symbol.
Kelter estimates if the company took on C$1 billion of debt and increased its leverage to three times EBITDA including restructuring or rent costs, it could fund a C$6.50 special dividend or buy back up to 12 percent of shares. If Tim Hortons increased its ratio of adjusted net debt to four times earnings with C$2 billion of debt it could fund a special dividend of $13 a share or buy back up to 23 percent of the stock, the note said.
Taking on that kind of debt would be a risk the company can ill afford amid headwinds in Canada as consumers carry record debt, said Stephen Groff, who helps run $6 billion as a portfolio manager at Cambridge Global Asset Management, a unit of CI Investments Inc. The ratio of Canadian household debt to disposable income rose to a record 165 percent in the first quarter from 164.7 percent in the previous period.
“What’s good for the company in the short term isn’t necessarily the best in the long term,” Groff, whose company owns Tim Hortons’ shares, said in an interview May 6. He said he favors sticking with management’s current strategy of trying to expand the business rather than taking on debt.
“Average sales per store appears destined for lower levels than that experienced in Canada, perhaps dictated by a more competitive environment in the U.S.,’ David Hartley, an analyst with Credit Suisse, said in a note April 24.
Hartley estimates closing the U.S. business would generate C$3.34 per share. He declined to be comment further.
‘‘Adding five times leverage to your balance sheet can be very risky,’’ said Dley. ‘‘While it may lead to short-term earnings accretion, investors that have been with Tim Hortons since the IPO essentially are likely not going to want to go that route.’’
To contact the reporter on this story: Ari Altstedter in Toronto at firstname.lastname@example.org
To contact the editor responsible for this story: David Scanlan at email@example.com