Posted by: Aaron Pressman on September 12, 2006
As an update and follow-up to my entry back in June dissing a new Powershares exchange-traded fund that invests in U.S.-traded shares of Indian companies, I’ll respond to a few emails I received about the original entry.
On Monday, one reader noted that the premium on the closed-end India Fund (Symbol: IFN) managed by Blackstone Asia Advisors has dropped from 26% in June to less than 1% now. There’s a great chart on ETFConnect’s page for the fund that tracks changes in the share price versus changes in the net asset value. As you can see, Indian stocks peaked back in April along with the fund’s premium. Since April, both the underlying Indian market (as represented by the NAV) and the closed-end fund’s share price have tanked, but the share price has dropped harder. Thus, the premium has collapsed because even with the Indian market falling, sentiment among closed-end fund buyers has dropped even more. That’s a pattern that has often rewarded investors in the past who bought on such dips in country funds.
A second email asked about the iShares MSCI India ETF that is based on a real India index. That is, the fund actually owns shares of dozens of Indian companies trading there. It’s more diversified and owns more companies than the Powershares product. But one catch — and it’s a showstopper — the iShares fund is only traded in Singapore! I called the pr departments of a couple of discount brokers and was told by spokespeople that Schwab and TD Ameritrade don’t allow access by ordinary investors to such securities. I’ve seen some bloggers write otherwise, but that was the official word I was given. A spokeswoman at Fidelity never got back to me.