Game Theory vs Behavioral Economics

Posted by: Michael Mandel on October 10

The economics blogs had a very positive reaction, in general, to this morning’s announcement of Robert Aumann and Thomas Schelling as the latest Nobelists in economics . For example, Tyler Cowen writes

I am happy to see Schelling — a fruitful generalist if there ever was one — and Aumann, a deeply philosophical thinker, get the nod. Aumann I don’t know personally, but there are few scholars I admire more than Thomas Schelling.

I’m going to take a bit of a different position. I agree that Schelling and Aumann are deserving prize winners. But their subject matter—game theory—has big problems.

In my opinion, despite today’s Nobel prize, game theory has hit a dead end. The more fruitful road forward leads through behavioral and experimental economics. (I say this as someone who wrote his doctoral dissertation on game theory).

In any real-life situation, game theory does not predict a single equilibrium. Instead, it typically offers a very wide range of possible outcomes. Moreover, game theory assumes a certain kind of rationality which has not been backed up by the facts.

Behavioral and experimental economics don’t start off by assuming rationality. Instead, they actually look at people’s real-world behavior, and then make predictions based on that. For example, see the 2002 Nobel Prize in economics, granted to Daniel Kahneman and Vernon Smith.

More about this later.


TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.businessweek.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/

Reader Comments

Paul Johnson

October 10, 2005 02:36 PM

Good points. The prize is awarded with a time lag, of 30 years or so. So what we will probably see in future is that the experimentalists and behavioralists, and more interdisciplinary work (law? sociology? geography?), gradually receive more recognition, as they become ever more mainstream.

A good indicator of the mainstream is the principles texts, and experiments at least, are penetrating there...

p>

Thank you for your interest. This blog is no longer active.

 

About

Michael Mandel, BW's award-winning chief economist, provides his unique perspective on the hot economic issues of the day. From globalization to the future of work to the ups and downs of the financial markets, Mandel-named 2006 economic journalist of the year by the World Leadership Forum-offers cutting edge analysis and commentary.

BW Mall - Sponsored Links

Buy a link now!