The iPod: crack-cocaine for thumbs, poison to competing brands

Posted by: Burth Helm on August 10, 2006

Yesterday my thumbs taught me a powerful lesson: a brilliantly-designed product is not just great for grabbing consumers’ eyes on the street, or for helping define a brand. Brilliant design can work as a dangerous and destructive weapon against competitors.

What am I talking about? I just tried out the new LG “Chocolate,”
blog Chocolate photo0.50.jpg

a sexy-looking phone cum digital music player that Verizon started hawking on July 31. It looks like a close cousin of the iPod, with a slim and simple piano-black body that slides shut to hide the number keys. When I saw it on my colleague’s desk, I raced over to check it out. It looked seriously cool. I wanted one.

Then I tried to use it.

This may sound silly, but I couldn’t get my thumbs to work the controls. Longing for my iPod, my right thumb kept trying to scroll by spinning around the wheel. The Chocolate’s “wheel” is actually a four-way button pad. But spinning my thumb is now so ingrained in my muscle memory, that I couldn’t do anything else. I repeatedly screwed everything up on the device by pushing the wrong buttons in a circular pattern. I got fed up and gave it back to my colleague. I wanted my iPod back. It’s how I imagine a good mp3 player feels like, not just how it looks.

I wonder, would a consumer from 2000 feel the same way? The user interface on the Chocolate is straightforward enough. If I had never experienced the brilliant intuitiveness of the iPod wheel, would I love Chocolate? I don’t know. I’ve been unconsciously trained to find all competing designs impossible.

Reader Comments

Spamouflage

August 14, 2006 3:33 PM

Very interesting: I'll have to test this assumption on unsuspecting friends. Kind of like blind testing... or not really!

wee

March 21, 2007 10:06 AM

i tried a friend's phone - Sony with touch pad screen, and while looking at a video I turned it horizontal, like an iPhone, u know..it didn't work :) and its not even out!!! man..its really true

Post a comment

 

About

News, opinions, inflammatory meanderings and occasional ravings about the world of advertising, marketing and media. By marketing editor Burt Helm, Innovation Editor Helen Walters, and senior correspondent Michael Arndt.

BW Mall - Sponsored Links

Buy a link now!