Posted by: Arik Hesseldahl on December 10
Last year Olga Kharif and I asked if Apple (AAPL) should open up the iPhone to software developers. The answer has since proven to be a resounding yes. Now William Hurley, better known as Whurley, an open source software advocate whose day job is at BMC Software (BMC) says he wants to take it a step further. The iPhone, he says, should become an open-source platform, and he lists five reasons why.
Here’s two of his five. It’s good for developers, and applications:
“Open source is becoming the default way to develop software in many industries. Why? Because a properly-managed, open environment leads to targeted, robust features and helps developers share code in a healthy coop-tition that helps everybody in the iPhone ecosystem.”
Also it will, he argues solidify Apple’s dominance.
“Apple’s got a rare opportunity to solidify dominance in a market by killing the competition in the cradle. An open source iPhone dulls some of Android’s luster. Given Google’s similar storefront approach, the open development environment is Android’s key differentiator.”
Um, big factor left out is the very large Java developer base for Android versus the Apple ObjectiveC minority.
Problematically, the post - as written - doesn't actually have any particular thesis.
In fact, Whurley himself hedges on the assertion for Open Sourcing it in his response to reader comments.
So, is Hurley saying that Linux is becoming the "default way"?
Apple is using "open source" selectively. It created WebKit, which is now open source". It did so as a counterpoint to Internet Explorer. It's done quite well, becoming the basis for Safari, Android, Adobe AIR, S60, and many others.
Developers only benefit if they can monetize their work, and make a living. We haven't seen Android's openness be a "key differentiator" yet.
I 100% agree and some fantastic open source apps for the iPhone are already in abundance, but you have to hack your iPhone to break Apples constraints (not that it's difficult to do anymore with all the software based iPhone hacking tools now available). But unfortunately, unless Apple can find a way to make money off open source software, I don't see them welcoming the open source idea.
The chances of the Apple Operating System becoming an Open Source Platform are none and none!
Apple's iPhone and application ecosystem are only a year old and their sales have already caught what it took RIM ten years to accomplish.
Apple iPhone and its development platform are a goldmine, not a utilatarian's panacea. My advise? Buy some Apple Stock. Publically available. Open Source. Terrific potential.
A blog on the daily doings of Apple and the many companies in its orbit, with insight and analysis by two longtime Apple-watchers BusinessWeek Senior Writer Peter Burrows and BusinessWeek.com Senior Technology Writer Arik Hesseldahl.
Leave us a voice message. Learn more.