Posted by: Arik Hesseldahl on February 22
I initially missed Steve’s comments on public schools, which he made earlier this week at an event where he appeared alongside Michael Dell. But, wow. If Steve were to write the occasional blog entry about his views on this or that public policy issue, it would certainly make for entertaining chatter.
Jay Greene, writing in The New York Sun has it right: It takes guts to say that teachers unions are the root of the problem in public education.
To say it in Texas, a state whose textbook purchases are so large that they usually set the standard for the rest of the nation, takes even more guts, mainly because its not likely to help Apple’s computer sales to public schools in the immediate future.
But say it he did: Schools he said, have become unionized in the “worst possible way.” I was once an education reporter, and having seen close-up how the union system protects lousy teachers and doesn’t properly encourage good ones, I have to agree.
One thing that strikes me as odd, is the politics of the people involved. Jobs is about as a dyed-in-the-wool Democrat as ever there was. In 2000, he gave $50,000 to the Democratic National Committee, for instance; His Wife Laurene Powell Jobs has been recently contributing to Barack Obama and to Hillary Rodham Clinton’s pre-candidacy organization known as HillPac. Here’s a link to a search form from the Center for Responsive Politics (sorry it doesn’t allow deep-linking to search results, so you’ll have to search for yourself). If you search for contributions from people with the last name of Jobs who live in California, you’ll that Steve and Laureen gave a sizable chunk of change to Who’s Who of prominent Democrats over the course of the last decade.
Michael Dell, for his part is a solid Republican, at least based on who he gives his money to, as shown in the CRP’s records: He’s made contributions to Tom DeLay and the “Every Republican Is Crucial” PAC (ERICPAC) among others in recent years. You’d think that so stalwart a Republican would have less-friendly things to say about unions, especially teachers unions. Republicans aren’t exactly popular with teachers unions. But he took the easy way out, and defended the unions, saying “the employer was treating his employees unfairly and that was not good. … So now you have these enterprises where they take good care of their people. The employees won, they do really well and succeed.” Dell opted to be less controversial on the subject, perhaps for fear of hurting his sales to schools, while his company is is experiencing a bit of a rough patch.
Jobs at least was honest, conceding that his opinions would likely cost Apple some business in Texas, and likely elsewhere. But he’s not exactly an uninformed person on the subject of education policy and what works and doesn’t in America’s public schools. In fact he’s probably better informed on the issue than most Americans. Wife Laurene is the president of the board of College Track, a Bay Area non-profit organization that helps underprivileged kids get into college; She also sits on the board of EdVoice an education lobbying and activist organization that focuses on changing California schools; And she sits on the board of the non-partisan New America Foundation (I’ve linked to its page on Education policy.)
So presuming that they talk often about her work with these non-profits, he’s not exactly new to the issues plaguing the public school system, and deserves a huge “atta boy” for daring to say something that’s politically incorrect in certain circules, and not likely to help line his personal pockets. Even Rush Limbaugh, whose opinions I can generally take or leave, chimed in with support for Jobs’ comments. And by the way, Rush, if my memory is correct, also happens to be a Mac user.
So all this serves, I think, to bolster my argument that Steve Jobs should blog. He has a lot of interesting things to say on topics more far-reaching than just what’s cool about the next version of the Mac OS or the iPod. How about it Steve?
Yes, BUT - after he leaves Apple.
The public is not ready for personal honesty that is not PC. (Pun very much intended!) And I suspect that Mr. Jobs is very much NOT PC in many areas.
When the public - instead of THINKING - wants to lie on the ground screaming or hold it's collective breath 'til it turns red in the face (unfortunately not with deserved embarrassment!) whenever someone says something they disagree with (and YES, Mac zealots are some of the major offenders) then it's better that he attend to running Apple and Pixar and influencing Disney. It would be too easy for media to twist any blog posts to their own ends. Not good for Apple when Jobs is so closely associated with their image.
Apple Helped How?
... and how did Steve Jobs represent Apple as a solution to the issues confronting education?
On Apple's time Steve Jobs should propose methods and procedures Apple is capable of bringing to the challenges faced by members of EDUCAUSE.
What ever his personal philosophies may be that influence how he prefers to spend his own money I wish he'd check them at the door.
Steve was invited to showcase Apple's vision for the education market. He was not invited to quarrel with or slander attendees.
On this day he was part of the problem, not part of Apple's solution. He needs to keep these Bad days to a minimum.
I agree that the teachers union is and has ruined the public schools. All their time is spent brain washing the students that the government owes them everything and that studying is not required. Teachers work so little time and have maximum benefits at the taxpayers expense. They nare one of the largest contributors to the steep decline of the United States as a great country.
Michael Dell contributed to Tom DeLay and Repubs? I thought he was smart!? Dude, I should not have bought a Dell! Nahh, I like my Dell, but I hope my money doesn't end up going to the Republican cause.
Steve Jobs is entitled to his opinion and Kudos for standing up for what he believes in. I prefer people to be open and honest because then guess what happens, you can have a debate and maybe start solving problems instead of just covering them up. I'm anti-union and pro-hardworking/honest people. I had 1 total union teacher in 8th grade math who made me lose 1 year of math. He wasn't there to teach. He was there for a paycheck. He is the one I will remember always. I had other teachers like him but he was the worst. He bragged about reaching tenure for god's sake, can't get rid of him. Wonderful liberal Massachusetts. Teachers like him hurt truly wonderful teachers who are worthy of so much more than what they get.
Boy this subject strikes my senses real hard. I have been a critic of unionized work force at work, among friends, and even among those who happen to have relatives work under union scheme and like them just fine. Here are my views of modern unionized work force: 1. Anti-competitive labor. 2. Promotes mediocrity. Union is long out-dated! Of course advocates will tell you that union protects workers' rights. I don't know what that truly means because when I look at the current labor laws, I couldn't think of the obvious right that employers violate and get away with it - is there? How about this guy at IBM that got fired for chatting porn at work? Does it seems his rights have been violated? If he were under union, he would likely have been reassigned to non-computer job, not fired.
While Jobs is certainly outspoken, I'm not sure putting his efforts into blogging is the best use of his time. Running Apple is. Even if I wasn't convinced about this before, my belief that Michael Dell is an idiot has just been reconfirmed.
A blog on the daily doings of Apple and the many companies in its orbit, with insight and analysis by two longtime Apple-watchers BusinessWeek Senior Writer Peter Burrows and BusinessWeek.com Senior Technology Writer Arik Hesseldahl.
Leave us a voice message. Learn more.