If sales weaken further after the stimulus checks are spent, a wave of bankruptcies may be forthcoming
Congress probably wasn't thinking about food last winter when it voted to send stimulus checks to 130 million U.S. households. President George W. Bush and other leaders hoped the package, amounting to more than $100 billion, would grease the wheels for broad consumer spending, thus lessening the severity of housing's collapse. "The growth package has to be big enough to make a difference in an economy as large and dynamic as ours," Bush said.
As the checks got cashed and consumer prices surged, however, large numbers of Americans spent the money in May and June on such basic needs as food, utilities, and gasoline. Sales at nearly all retailers—save for those selling low-cost food—were dismal. And that's proving to be a source of deep worry for a broad array of retailers of everything from electronics and autos to home furnishings. "There are already too many building material suppliers than there are buyers, and auto dealers who have their parking lots full of SUVs they can't sell," says Brian Bethune, chief U.S. financial economist at Global Insight, a market analysis firm.
The bulk of the money, which started going out in May, has been disbursed, with the last checks already in the mail. Since May 1, the Treasury has pumped out $78 billion as tax rebates and transfers. But U.S. retail sales rose a mere 0.1% in June, after a 0.8% jump in May caused by the stimulus checks, according to the Commerce Dept. Specialty retail and department stores reported dismal sales: Limited Brands' (LTD) sales fell 9% in June and 6% in May, J.C. Penney's (JCP) fell 2.4% and 4.4%, while Abercrombie & Fitch's (ANF) sales declined 3% and 1%, respectively.
Produce in Particular
Yet at the level of staples, sales have been humming. Wal-Mart Stores (WMT) and warehouse clubs Costco (COST) and BJ's (BJ) have been among the prime beneficiaries. Wal-Mart reported a 6.1% sales increase in June, following a 4% gain in May. Costco posted increases of 9% and 7% in June and May, while BJ's Wholesale Club's sales surged 16.5% and 13.4%, respectively, mostly from perishable food and gasoline. "Overall, our food business continued to be strong," said Jeff Elliott, Costco's finance chief, on a July 10 conference call. "Our fresh foods category showed the strongest results in produce." No wonder that Family Dollar Stores (FDO) recently boosted its space for food at 2,700 of its 6,500 stores, which helped push up June sales 8%.
The unease among many retailers this summer is compounded by the fact that their own cost for goods and shipping is soaring with high gasoline prices. In the past six months, such chains as Ann Taylor (ANN) and Foot Locker (FL) have closed hundreds of stores. Further cuts could be forthcoming. "Specialty retailers who are already hurting will be in deeper trouble and will have to cut back on capacity, as consumers are being ultraconservative," Bethune predicts.
Others are expecting even worse fates, similar to Sharper Image and Linens 'n Things, both of which have declared bankruptcy. "Another wave of bankruptcies is coming, and it's not going to be pretty," says Lawrence Gottlieb, an expert on retail bankruptcies at law firm Cooley Godward Kronish. "It is the perfect storm of high inflation, no liquidity, and negative consumer spending."
A Surfeit of Risk
As a result, many retailers are battening down the hatches, slashing capital spending, and preparing for worse. After all, if Americans spent their $600 stimulus checks primarily on food and other basic necessities, chances are slim that consumers will splurge on much else when the money from Uncle Sam dries up. Home Depot (HD), the nation's second-largest retailer, closed 15 stores, the first time in the company's 30-year history that it has closed stores because of underperformance. "We are seeing significant pressure on the cost side as the price of basic commodities goes up," CEO Frank Blake said on a May 20 earnings conference call. "There isn't a well-worn path guiding us on what all these pressures will do to our business…, but there is more risk than opportunities for the remainder of the year."
Wall Street has slashed forecasts for the retailers. Goldman Sachs (GS) retail analyst Adrianne Shapira lowered her 12-month price targets on retail stocks 16%, on average, to reflect reduced earnings expectations for the rest of the year. "Given the ongoing macro [economic] jitters and the prospect of further, extended weakness, we feel it prudent to take a more conservative stance," she wrote. Citi's (C) Deborah Weinswig warned that "consumers will continue to pare back discretionary purchases to meet rising food and fuel costs in the second half of the year."
Even better-performing retailers have failed to impress analysts. For instance, shares of Family Dollar Stores, which in June reported an 8% increase in same-store sales, didn't stir. Charles Grom, a retail analyst at JPMorgan (JPM), has an underweight rating on the stock.
Grom noted in a report that the discount stores' sales were increasingly coming from low-margin consumables, such as food, while sales of apparel, accessories, and home products were declining. Besides, he pointed out, the chain's current sales were boosted by the stimulus checks. "We'd question the sustainability of current sales momentum," said Grom. Indeed, that's exactly what worries all the discounters right now.