The automaker enjoyed a solid second quarter, but it still needs to win over U.S. unions and win back U.S. buyers
For the second week in a row, a U.S. auto company announced a profitable second quarter. Just a week after Ford (F) surprised Wall Street with a profit for the second quarter, rival General Motors (GM) doubled investor expectations with an $891 million profit. But there are continuing warning signs that Detroit has a lot of work to do.
Still, the surprise profits from both Detroit automakers are positive signs that more than two years of ongoing restructuring is starting to take hold. GM not only beat the Street's forecast but its results are a big turnaround from the $3.4 billion loss from the same quarter a year ago. And without $520 million in one-time charges, including $374 million to help restructure its former parts unit, the bankrupt Delphi, GM says it would have made $1.4 billion.
Price-Chopping and Union Wrangling
GM's results are an important incremental step on what looks like a long road to a full recovery. GM lost $39 million in North America in the quarter, but without some one-time charges the carmaker would have made $78 million at home. That means its largest business (which accounts for 63% of revenue) is running at about the break-even point. Says GM Vice-Chairman and Chief Financial Officer Frederick "Fritz" Henderson, "We have to continue to focus on revenue and costs, particularly in North America."
While its overseas operations are improving, sales are still falling at home. GM's North American market share fell from 23.8% to 22.6% and revenue dropped $1.3 billion, to $29.6 billion.
Plus, GM is spending more money to keep sales of its Chevrolet Silverado and GMC Sierra large pickup trucks up (see BusinessWeek.com, 1/23/07, "Chevy's Silverado Lining"). The automaker is offering 0% financing on the trucks, which it relies on for big profits. GM has a lot of pickups on dealer lots, Lehman Brothers (LEH) analyst Brian Johnson said in a report, so higher incentives or lower production could hurt profits later on. "We remain concerned that there may be some payback in the second half," Johnson wrote.
Some other consumer come-ons are costing GM more money as well. GM said adding to its warranty cost reserve funds hit profits to the tune of $500 million. That hit to the bottom line came in part from rising warranty costs and a 10-year, 100,000-mile, engine and transmission warranty that GM started offering car buyers last year.
Health-care costs also remain a big issue. Retiree benefits cost GM $500 million in the second quarter and $1 billion so far this year. The company hopes to wring big concessions on benefits from the United Auto Workers this summer. The company may even try to give the union a big bundle of cash—analysts estimate it to be at least 60% of GM's $60 billion long-term liability—in exchange for getting the UAW to manage its members' health-care benefits.
Cash Flow: More In, More Out
On the upside, GM's profits helped the company generate cash in the quarter. The company has been burning cash for the past few years as it restructures its sprawling network of factories and buys out workers. But in the second quarter, GM actually generated $1.1 billion in cash.
Despite this growth, Henderson expects GM to burn cash for the year. That could be in part because the third quarter is typically weak for carmakers and because GM has spent just $2.9 billion of its $8 billion capital expenditures budget for new models this year. That means the company has back-loaded some of its cash outlays.
Some analysts aren't convinced that GM has its cash problems in hand yet. Morgan Stanley (MS) analyst Jonathan Steinmetz pointed out in a research note that GM's cash flow is about breakeven, despite the fact that the company is at a high point in its schedule of launching new models.
International Success Bolsters Bottom Line
As GM tries to fulfill Chairman and Chief Executive Officer G. Richard Wagoner Jr.'s promise of generating "robust profits" from its North American business, success in international markets is helping tremendously.
The automaker earned $686 million from its businesses in Europe, Asia, Latin America, and the Middle East. Europe has been the biggest boon, making $236 million in the quarter, a jump of $93 million. GM's German Adam Opel unit has been shown a real turnaround over the past year. China continues to be a bright spot, too. GM made $122 million there.
But GM can't rely on overseas markets to carry the load, nor can it rely on its GMAC Commercial Finance arm. GMAC made $239 million in the quarter, but GM gets only $139 million of it since Cerberus Capital Management now owns 51% of the lender.
GM knows that getting back to strong profits at home will be a tough slog. The company will keep pushing its unions and suppliers to trim costs, but Henderson says that the company needs to build revenue and get better prices for its cars. In some cases, that means rebuild some of its weaker brands to command better pricing, and it takes time, he said. "There has never been a turnaround in this business ever just on cost cutting," Henderson said.
To deliver Wagoner's goal, GM needs real concessions this summer. And in the long run, the carmaker has to start finding more new buyers in the U.S.