No one ever said that the fight for free trade was easy, especially in light of rising public opposition to globalization. But while Administration trade officials vow not to turn back, the President may have no choice but to shift his focus from Big Reform to incremental gains.
Doha was launched in 2001 amid high hopes that U.S. and European farm subsidy reductions could help developing nations and spur global growth. By also lowering barriers on food imports in Europe, the U.S., and Japan, the pact aimed to bolster many African, Asian, and Latin American economies where up to two-thirds of the population works in farming. At the same time, the U.S. hoped to end rampant Third World piracy of patents and copyrights and to lower tariffs on U.S. exports while increasing overseas opportunities for U.S. service companies.The Art of the Possible
Instead, Doha has become a Rubik's Cube of interlocking parts, few of which are aligned. France has balked at trimming subsidies to its inefficient farmers and threatens to capsize a modest European Union subsidy-trimming plan. Developing nations, led by Brazil and India, threaten to retain import barriers and keep making knockoff pharmaceuticals and software. The upshot is that Doha is pinned under the weight of its own ambitions.
But trade experts say that considerable progress could still be made if the process were scaled back. After all, the Clinton Administration accomplished much outside of the framework of massive trade talks, forging pacts with China and with NAFTA partners Mexico and Canada, and leading the world to a global telecom accord.
Indeed, the eight-year-long Uruguay Round talks that created the World Trade Organization in 1995 left everyone so exhausted that the signers predicted it would take years for the developing world to adjust. That's proving prescient.
The key to a more manageable Doha deal: Pursue the art of the possible. "Each side could agree to take something off the table," says Kimberly Elliott, an analyst at the Center for Global Development. To facilitate trade flows, rich nations could increase aid to poorer states for road and port construction. Poor nations could agree to let Europe and America keep some protections on sensitive farm sectors such as dairy, meat, and sugar. Washington could ease off its demands for dramatic drops in barriers to trade in services and for an abrupt end to generic drugmaking in the developing world.
Clearly, neither the EU nor the U.S. is ready to confront politically powerful farm interests. But most of the 148 WTO members believe in the goal of free trade. That's why they are members. Their citizens, though, are less comfortable with the wrenching changes wrought by rapid globalization. A few years of consolidation and slower change may be the ticket now. Northrop Grumman (NOC
) reported that shipbuilding profits in the third quarter were off by $165 million due to Hurricane Katrina, but shareholders can take heart. If the U.S. Navy gets its way, the company will get a cash infusion far greater than that. The Navy wants to pour nearly $2 billion into Northrop Grumman's shipyards in Louisiana and Mississippi. The tab covers everything from the costs of labor disruption to replacement of technical manuals and other items assumed to be destroyed.
Not everyone is onboard. "Something's rotten in Denmark," says a Senate GOP aide. "Why should U.S. taxpayers pay these costs?" One reason is the government insures arms makers against acts of nature. A company spokesman says the cash will cover the Navy's losses and get shipbuilding back on schedule. In business, timing is everything -- and Virginia groups' timing was lousy this year. With GOP gubernatorial candidate Jerry Kilgore leading in October polls, business organizations hopped on his bandwagon. Backers included many executives who four years ago had supported Democratic Governor Mark Warner, a former wireless telephone CEO.
But Kilgore's corporate corps miscalculated. The Republican's campaign cratered, and Lieutenant Governor Tim Kaine, a pro-business, fiscally conservative Democrat, easily won. Kaine says he'll forgive old differences and work with business to build Virginia's economy. But Democrats are unlikely to forget anytime soon.