Putting a Price Tag on Your Company
Even in today's strong market, don't wait till you have to sell to find out what it's worth
The first of a two-part series
Glenna Barnes started Pets Day Out, a pet grooming and boarding business
in Duncanville, Tex., with an initial investment of $45,000 in 1992 and
manageable volume of 100 pets a week. Six years later, she was working
12 hours a day and handling 500 animals a week. "It grew so fast, it was
just a little bit more than I could handle by myself," she says. Overwhelmed,
Barnes decided to sell. She contacted a business broker in June and had
a tentative agreement in July. She closed in September for $322,000 --
about 2.5 times her net annual profit. "That was right around what I expected
to get," she says.
Barnes's good fortune is no isolated case. Small businesses are sitting
pretty, according to business brokers and other valuation experts from
across the U.S. Thanks to a hearty economy, buyer confidence is strong -- and financing is cheap.
"This is about as good a time to sell a small business as ever," says Steve Benson,
an owner and broker with VR Business Brokers in Huntington Beach, Calif.
UP ON THE BLOCK. The business valuation numbers are persuasive: In the first half of 1998,
the average sale price for a small business rose 8.3%, to $458,000, up from $423,000 in 1997. This is
according to the latest survey from VR Business Brokers, which has tracked
sales of U.S. businesses valued at $500,000 or less since 1992. What's more, small ventures
are selling faster, VR found -- within 174 days on average, vs. 192 in 1997.
Across the country, several markets look strong: VR found demand for card
and gift stores, florists, prepared food businesses, liquor stores, and
auto/truck service businesses. A November, 1998, International Business Brokers
Assn. survey of U.S. private investment groups and midmarket intermediaries
shows that manufacturers worth $10 million or less sold for five
times earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization,
or EBITDA, while distribution and service companies captured between
4.5 and 4.9 times EBITDA. "Niche companies are remarkably attractive in
today's marketplace," says IBBA President Michael S. Hoesly, who adds that
EBITDA multiples haven't changed that dramatically but dollar values have risen
considerably in the past few years.
Conditions sound tempting. But most entrepreneurs who might want
to take advantage of the current market are in no position to do so. That's
because they don't know what their companies are worth. In the absence
of such benchmarks as a public stock price -- or even the relative transparency
of real estate prices -- most entrepreneurs find out what the market thinks when they want
to cash out or bring in an outside investor or at major turning points
in their lives, such as divorce or transfer of ownership to a child. At
worse, an owner's heirs get stuck with the task.
Waiting until you must know the worth of your business is a mistake, says Mike Hartman, managing
director of Valuemetrics Inc., a business valuation and advisory company in
Atlanta. "For a manager to run things properly and make the right
decisions," says Hartman, "he or she has got to have a sense of what the value of the business
is." Moreover, if a company faces financial problems that hurt its value, knowing
the valuation in advance gives the owner a chance to fix them -- instead of swallowing a discounted
price.
VALUATION VARIABLES. Another reason not to wait till you're under pressure to sell is that
valuing privately held businesses is not a matter of science: There are
several ways to go about it (see "What's the Magic Number?"), and it's important to choose the
right one and feel confident in the assessment.
For example, many entrepreneurs -- especially mom-and-pop businesses --
get their valuations from business brokers to save money, rather than paying
accountants or lawyers for independent assessments. Since an owner isn't
obliged to use a broker, the assessment looks like a freebie. Of course,
it isn't. If the broker does the deal, he or she will charge a commission
of up to 12%. In any case, John W. Newman, a senior lecturer of entrepreneurship
and management at Babson College in Wellesley, Mass., contends that it's
worth paying for an independent assessment. Why? A broker's ultimate
interest is to push the deal through, and that may color the price he or
she gives. "I would argue it's money well spent," Newman says of an assessment.
And a good broker won't dissuade you from getting a second
opinion. "If you have any concerns [about a valuation], we encourage you
to get an independent valuation," says Benson of VR Business Brokers. "But
a good broker will have the information and resources to provide to the
buyer so they can determine what the fair-market value of the business
is."
How can you tell if your company is being fairly evaluated? Of course,
the core value of a company is based on its earnings, prospects, financial
health, assets, reputation, customer base, and the quality of its management.
But an array of external factors can make the price fluctuate, and their impact is -- as much as anything -- a matter of timing.
For example, retail businesses tend to do well and are likely to garner
better prices when the local or national economy is strong. And
oil-services companies thrive when oil prices are up, and so on.
Other price-affecting factors include market fashions. Take the Internet. Although few doubt
that doing business on the World Wide Web has great potential, the results
have yet to show in profit figures. Still, a certain market hysteria
has developed, and many small Internet companies are posting extremely
high valuations.
The worth of a small businesses can also change depending
on who's interested in it -- and why. A strategic buyer, someone who wants
to purchase a small enterprise because it complements an existing business, will
often pay more than someone who has no other concerns. By the same token,
a buyer who knows a seller is desperate has good reason to believe he'll
get a better price by staying aloof.
If getting a fair valuation sounds like a complex task, there's good
news: "What you're really looking for is a ballpark value," says Newman.
"After you decide to sell, it becomes a negotiation issue. And the precise
value will never be established until two parties come to some sort of
agreement." And, as in any negotiation, the better you know the worth of
your offering, the stronger your position.
By Laura Castañeda in Philadelphia
TABLE: What's the Magic Number?
To: FINANCE
|