Deciphering the Balance Sheet, from Manila to Miami
Accounting rules vary from country to country. That's just one reason why you need a professional
Q: I have been running the numbers on the profit-and-loss (P&L)
statement for a new business venture and at the same time computing return
on investment. In the process, the following question came up: If I take
out a loan for startup capital, is it correct to include those loan payments
as part of my expenses?
--A.B., Manila
A: Few questions in accounting are simple, which is why entrepreneurs
are usually advised to hire a certified public accountant familiar with
small-business needs rather than try to do the number-crunching themselves.
It's almost impossible to give a universal answer to accounting questions,
since each country has a set of "generally accepted accounting principles" that
its CPAs are expected to follow and its own tax laws, which affect how things are
accounted for and even business strategies, such as mergers, acquisitions, and corporate
structure. As the rules in the Philippines may vary from those in the U.S.
as set forth by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants,
you'll need to consult with a local practitioner. That said, here's a rundown on
some basic principles.
When you start a business, you or your bookkeeper should draw up financial
documents, including a P&L statement, a statement of cash flow, and
a balance sheet. Put simply, the P&L shows the operating performance
of the business: how much money the company is making and how much it costs
to keep the company running. The balance sheet shows the company's position
in terms of assets and liabilities at any point in time. The statement
of cash flow shows where the company's cash is going -- into stock, equipment,
rental deposits, or elsewhere.
Now let's look at how you account for a loan on those statements. With
a conventional bank loan, you'll pay back both principal and interest
over time. Each is handled somewhat differently on your books. First, your payments
come out of cash flow your company generates and
should be listed on your cash-flow statement. Next, let's take the interest
component: In the U.S., says Barry Garfield, CPA and partner in the Melville
(N.Y.) accounting firm of Holtz Rubenstein & Co., "the interest
portion of the payment is [tax-]deductible and would be expensed in the
profit-and-loss statement." The loan principal gets recorded as a
liability on your balance sheet, while the funds that you received are
initially recorded as an asset -- cash on hand, which diminishes as you
spend it. How that's accounted for depends on what you use the money for.
Meanwhile, as you pay down the debt, you reduce your liability correspondingly.
Calculating the return on your investment in the business is another
matter. The way to compare investment opportunities is to project the internal
rate of return -- the rate of interest at which the net present value (the
value today) of the payments from an investment over a certain period equals
the cost of that investment. Compare that to the rate of return investors
require -- the hurdle rate -- for a given level of risk. If your business
can give investors a higher rate, they'll bite.
"Your aftertax net income, plus depreciation, is the figure that you
use to calculate your internal rate of return," says Paul Ratoff, a Los
Angeles business consultant with the accounting firm of Moss Adams LLP.
You want to be conservative when projecting return on investment, experts
say, so that your investors will be pleasantly surprised if their investment
starts paying off more quickly than expected, rather than disappointed that
the returns are not what you promised. You also must figure in cushions
for the unexpected, like bad weather or fickle consumer demand. Say your
merchandise sells wonderfully the first year but goes out of fashion the next.
Instead of the rosy financial picture you had planned, you might be
left with shelves full of unsold inventory that you'll have to discount.
If you're absolutely determined to do it yourself, there are plenty of books
about accounting -- at all levels of difficulty. Alternatively, you
might try contacting a local business school and asking if their accounting
students set up books for small businesses as part of their coursework
-- under the supervision of a qualified instructor, of course.
By the time your business gets going, you'll need an accountant
to help you with your tax preparation anyway, and if you're going to approach
a bank for a loan, the bank's managers will probably give you a list of accountants
they have worked with. Here's another idea: Barry Garfield's
firm is a member of an international group of accounting firms, DFK International,
that includes affiliates in close to 80 countries around the world -- and its directory
includes the Philippines.
Have a question about running your business? Ask our small-business experts. Send us an E-mail at editors@businessweekmail.com, or write to Smart Answers, BW Online, 46th Floor, 1221 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020. Please include your real name and phone number in case we need more information; only your initials and city will be printed. Because of the volume of mail, we won't be able to respond to all questions personally.

|