What Price a Startup?
Valuing a company that barely exists is a subjective process
Q: I hope to launch a property portal site early in 2000.
How do I value my startup? I have financial projections for the first two years of operation, but I'm not sure what range of
valuation I should insist on. Should I use an advisory firm for this process?
Attaching a value to a company that's not yet operating is very tricky. Your projections, even if they are based on solid
comparisons and thorough research, are really just educated guesses. Whether your new company succeeds or not depends on the
strength of your product, your market potential, and perhaps most important, the experience and dedication of your management team.
The risk associated with financing your new company also is a factor in calculating the company's "pre-money" valuation, the amount
it's worth before a venture capitalist or angel investor takes a stake.
There are no hard-and-fast rules for valuing a startup. "There are some Internet startups going into the funding process with
valuations of $2 million, or even $6 million or $8 million," says Peter Cowen, an investment banker and president of Peter Cowen
& Associates, based in Westwood, Calif., "but they have strong management teams in place, proof of concept, and a very
compelling composition with a great upside." Strategic alliances that give a company early outlets for its products or a marketing
advantage, as well as a strong management team with relevant industry experience, also plump up an early business valuation, he
CANNED NUMBERS. Stuart Skorman, founder and CEO of San Francisco-based HungryMinds.com and founder of REEL.com, says that
earnings projections are nearly meaningless unless you already have a strong track record in your industry. "Venture capitalists
that you present your idea to are the best, most qualified people to objectively set the value of the company, based on the criteria
of what they think is the potential of the overall business," Skorman says. You can hire a professional business-valuation firm to
crunch some numbers for you, but unless the consultants have extraordinary cachet, professional investors will likely ignore their
estimates. "The venture capitalists that are
looking at new companies all day, every day, are usually familiar with
comparable businesses, and they are the best qualified to put a value on your startup," he says.
You can purchase valuation software and try to come up with a
"canned" number for your company. A better use of your energies is to write a credible business plan that conveys your excitement
about the company, says Colin Gabriel, a mergers-and-acquisitions professional and
author of How to Sell Your Business and Get What You Want. "Beauty is in the eye of the beholder and so is value," Gabriel
says. "Present your business plan to as many venture-capital investors as is practicable. Those who are interested will propose
investment terms, and they won't be much influenced by an asking price. The market is enormously competitive among investors for
attractive opportunities, and the fear of losing the deal to a competitor will drive investors to propose attractive terms, if they
Have a question about running your business? Ask our small-business experts. Send us an E-mail at email@example.com, or write to Smart Answers, BW Online, 46th Floor, 1221 Avenue of the Americas, New
York, NY 10020. Please include your real name and phone number in case we need more information; only your initials and city will be printed. Because of the
volume of mail, we won't be able to respond to all questions personally.
Want to post a reply? Let us know what you think.