Bloomberg News

Coloplast Said to Pay $16 Million to Settle Vaginal-Mesh Suits

March 04, 2014

Coloplast A/S (COLOB), the Danish maker of medical products, agreed to pay about $16 million to settle lawsuits accusing it of injuring women with its vaginal-mesh inserts, three people familiar with the accord said.

Officials of Humlebaek, Denmark-based Coloplast agreed in January to resolve about 400 suits over the inserts, which are designed to support internal organs, said the people, who asked not to be identified because they weren’t authorized to speak publicly about the settlement. The accord will provide an average payment of about $40,000 for each claimant, they said.

Settlement talks are continuing with other manufacturers facing thousands of suits over their vaginal-mesh inserts, including C.R. Bard (BCR:US) Inc. and a unit of Endo Health Solutions (ENDO:US) Inc., the people said. Some implant makers, such as Johnson & Johnson (JNJ:US), the world’s biggest maker of health-care products, have declined to discuss out-of-court settlements, the people added.

“It appears that momentum is building for some type of global resolution as more of these vaginal-mesh cases settle,” Carl Tobias, who teaches product-liability law at the University of Richmond in Virginia, said in an e-mail.

Ulla Lundhus, a spokeswoman for Coloplast, declined to comment on the report of a settlement.

Case Consolidation

Coloplast is best known as a maker of ostomy and urine bags for post-surgical use. In January, the company raised its sales forecast after reporting double-digit growth in all business units during its first quarter.

Many of the cases against Coloplast and other implant makers in federal courts around the U.S. have been consolidated before U.S. District Judge Joseph Goodwin in Charleston, West Virginia, for information exchanges and bellwether trials.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration ordered Coloplast, Johnson & Johnson, Bard and more than 30 other vaginal-implant makers in 2012 to study rates of organ damage and complications linked to the implants.

J&J officials have said in court filings that more than 1 million women have received the inserts during the past 15 years to help hold up internal organs or treat incontinence.

Women contend they’ve suffered organ damage and pain after the implants eroded and have sued New Brunswick, New Jersey-based J&J, Natick, Massachusetts-based Boston Scientific Corp. (BSX:US), Malvern, Pennsylvania-based Endo and Bard, which is based in Murray Hill, New Jersey.

Settlement Talks

Officials of Bard, Endo and Boston Scientific are continuing discussions about resolving vaginal-mesh lawsuits as part of a global settlement of cases, the people said.

Scott Lowry, a Bard spokesman, Endo spokesman Blaine Davis and Denise Kaigler, a Boston Scientific spokeswoman, didn’t return calls seeking comment on whether they are continuing settlement discussions.

Matthew Johnson, a spokesman for J&J’s Ethicon unit, said the company doesn’t comment on legal strategy. Ethicon makes J&J’s lines of vaginal-mesh inserts.

Coloplast executives have declined to seek a blanket settlement of cases over the company’s implants and instead are settling inventories of cases collected by individual plaintiffs’ lawyers, according to the people.

Coloplast has been sued over implants including the Novasilk-Synthetic Flat Mesh System and the Aris-Transobturator lines, according to court filings.

‘Buy Peace’

Lana Varney, one of Coloplast’s lawyers, told Goodwin this year that the medical-device maker had “reached a resolution with one major inventory of cases,” according to a transcript of a Jan. 9 hearing in West Virginia. She didn’t specify how many cases were being settled or for what amounts.

The judge said the plaintiffs’ lawyers’ inventory of cases that settled “was fairly large, though, several hundred cases, wasn’t it?” according to the transcript.

“Yes, your honor, a significant size,” Varney replied.

Coloplast’s lawyer told the judge the company had made “offers to five other groups and we are optimistic we will be able to reach agreement on resolution” of some of the lawyers’ inventories, according to the transcript.

Varney also said Coloplast’s goal was to work out comprehensive settlements with individual lawyers that resolve all vaginal-mesh cases over her client’s products.

“We’d like to address the entire inventory so that we can buy our peace and move on down the road,” she said, according to the transcript.

The consolidated cases are In Re: Coloplast Corp Pelvic Support System Products Liability Litigation, 12-md-2387, U.S. District Court, Southern District of West Virginia (Charleston).

To contact the reporter on this story: Jef Feeley in Wilmington, Delaware at

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Michael Hytha at

China's Killer Profits

Companies Mentioned

  • BCR
    (CR Bard Inc)
    • $168.87 USD
    • 3.03
    • 1.79%
  • ENDO
    (Endocan Corp)
    • $0.02 USD
    • 0.00
    • 3.55%
Market data is delayed at least 15 minutes.
blog comments powered by Disqus