Bloomberg News

Raped Egypt Women Wish Death Over Life as Crimes Ignored

March 07, 2013

Raped Egypt Women Wish Death Over Life With Male Crimes Ignored

Hundreds of women were back in Tahrir after the Shura Council members’ comments, brandishing kitchen knives to protest gender-based violence and political and religious leaders’ endorsement of the widely held belief that women invite attacks. Photograph: AFP via Getty Images

The back seat of Joanna Joseph’s Hyundai is still stained with the young woman’s blood.

Joseph, a volunteer with Operation Anti-Sexual Harassment, helped rescue the 19-year-old from Cairo’s Tahrir Square on Jan. 25 as Egyptians marked the second anniversary of the uprising that toppled Hosni Mubarak. Walking through the square on her way home from work, the victim was accosted by a gang that raped her with a knife, according to the doctor who operated on her and witnesses of the attack. It was one of 29 assaults documented that day in Tahrir, which has been plagued by sexual violence since it became the center of political protests.

The wounds weren’t only physical. “She kept saying, ‘It would have been better that I’d died than live with such a shameful memory,’” Joseph, 46, said, recalling the drive to the hospital. The woman’s aunt said she tells neighbors her niece broke her leg to explain why she doesn’t leave the house. They both declined to be named, fearing dishonor to their family.

The case has helped galvanize human rights campaigners as Egypt’s Islamist-led government rewrites the penal code and definitions of gender-based violence. It has also underscored the uphill fight against society’s tendency to blame the victim and absolve men, and the state, of responsibility, said Mozn Hassan, head of Nazra for Feminist Studies, a Cairo-based nonprofit organization.

The Tahrir Square attacks constitute “a major crime against women,” said Nehad Abo Komsan, head of the Egyptian Center for Women’s Rights. “It can’t be brushed off.”

Female ‘Devils’

Some political and religious leaders have tried to do just that, she said. The anti-harassment group documented 19 assaults -- women being groped, violated, their clothes ripped off -- on Jan. 25 in the square. Tahrir Bodyguards, another volunteer organization, chronicled 10. There have been no arrests.

While the state-run National Council for Women condemned the violence and opened a probe, council members declined to be interviewed about it, nor would they talk about the measure they’re writing to criminalize sexual harassment and assault. Mohamed Abdel-Salam, a spokesman for the 30-member council, 20 of whom are women, said he didn’t have copies of drafts of the bill. It’s supposed to be sent to the new parliament that will be seated after general elections are held.

Some male members of the Shura Council, Egypt’s temporary legislative authority, said in a public session that what happened Jan. 25 should teach women to avoid dangerous places, and suggested segregation during political gatherings.

Their remarks came after a popular preacher known as Abu Islam said in an online video that female protesters want to be raped. “Those women have no shame, no fear and not even femininity,” he said. “They are devils.”

‘Societal Roots’

That mindset is common, said Hassan of Nazra for Feminist Studies. “Sexual harassment has tormented the country for decades, and its significance has been downplayed,” she said. “The state has ignored a problem with deep societal roots.”

Hundreds of women were back in Tahrir after the Shura Council members’ comments, brandishing kitchen knives to protest gender-based violence and political and religious leaders’ endorsement of the widely held belief that women invite attacks. A 2008 study by the Center for Women’s Rights said 62 percent of men admitted to sexually harassing women, and 53 percent said women who are harassed “bring it on.”

The proposed law the women’s council is writing may replace those against “hitk ird,” Arabic for assault against morality, which covers a range of crimes from touching a woman’s breast to cutting her genitalia with a knife.

Death Penalty

Rape in Egypt is punishable by death or life imprisonment, according to a law instituted by the military council that replaced Mubarak and ruled until the election of President Mohamed Mursi. It’s unclear whether anyone has been tried or sentenced under this law because the Interior Ministry doesn’t make the information public, according to Dalia Abdel Hameed, a gender rights officer at the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights, a nonprofit in Cairo.

In Egypt -- which has a population of 83 million -- reports of “hitk ird” rose to 349 in 2012 from 330 in 2011, and reported rapes went to 129 from 119, Abdel Fattah Othman, an assistant to the Interior Minister, told the state-run Al-Ahram newspaper.

Most women are too ashamed to go to the police or even tell their relatives, said Joseph, the volunteer who drove the 19- year-old to the hospital.

“The victim makes up stories for her parents, because she’s scared they might blame her or lock her up inside the house,” she said. “If the attack leaves bruises, she’d just cover up her body, and avoid contact with her parents till they’re healed. That’s a real load on the victim.”

‘Well Trained’

None of the Jan. 25 assault cases were reported to authorities by Operation Anti-Sexual Harassment, according to Abdel Hameed, who also volunteers with the group.

“We believe that since the police themselves are perpetrators of sexual violence crimes,” she said, “they cannot in any way be a channel for legal remedies for sexual violence survivors.”

Law enforcement officers and soldiers have been accused of assaulting women during anti-government demonstrations. Activists started a public awareness campaign in December 2011 called Liars to counter official denials, after the publication around the world of a photograph of a girl being dragged across the square, her black robe lifted to reveal a blue bra, the shoe of a soldier about to strike her chest.

Police are aware of the case of the 19-year-old because the medical report detailing her treatment was given to authorities, as required by law, said Samy Mounir, the gynecologist who operated on her at Al-Salam hospital.

Inflicting Damage

“She had bruises around her breasts, and was bleeding heavily,” the doctor said. The knife sliced through her vagina and ripped part of her anus, requiring surgery, he said.

“She told me that the people who did this said it was for her own good, and someone put a hand over her mouth to prevent her from screaming as they hurt her and ripped her clothes off,” he said. Her attackers, he said, were “well trained people,” knowing how to inflict damage.

The head of the women’s council, Mervat Tallawy, said at a news conference that assaults on female protesters appear to be led by organized gangs that are politically motivated. Magda Adly, head of Cairo’s El Nadeem Center for Rehabilitation of Victims of Violence, said the goal is to cause emotional as well as physical harm.

“These are plans not devised by normal thugs,” she said. The way they operate leaves women confused, not knowing who is protecting you and who is assaulting you in the mob. It puts women in a very difficult mental place.’’

Bolder Women

Women are becoming more outspoken. A protester who said she was gang-raped during a demonstration in November gave an interview on national television, describing how a mob of men pulled her across Tahrir Square and into a side-street. “They kept saying, ‘We’re trying to protect you,’ as they dragged me,” she said.

Protests have become a regular occurrence across Egypt, where roads are clogged and cities sometimes all but shut down as demonstrators rally. Police stations have been burned and workers have shut down ports, and anti-Mursi graffiti lines the walls of the presidential palace.

Female activists said they will continue to participate, and encourage women to speak out.

“This is our fight,” said Reem Labib, who said she was sexually assaulted at two protests last year and now volunteers with Operation Anti-Sexual Harassment. “We’re fighting it.”

To contact the reporters on this story: Salma El Wardany in Cairo at selwardany@bloomberg.net; Nadine Marroushi in Cairo at nmarroushi@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Andrew J. Barden at barden@bloomberg.net; Gary Putka at gputka@bloomberg.net


Tim Cook's Reboot
LIMITED-TIME OFFER SUBSCRIBE NOW
 
blog comments powered by Disqus