Bloomberg News

Democrats Amend Platform to Back Jerusalem as Israel Capital

September 05, 2012

Democrats amended their party platform today to restore references to God and Jerusalem, after the omission of language naming the city as the capital of Israel sparked an outcry in their party and fueled a fresh round of attacks from Republican nominee Mitt Romney.

Party delegates meeting in Charlotte, North Carolina, approved the two amendments after three voice votes and over the objections of many on the convention floor, who booed after chairman Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa announced the results.

Democrats reinstated language from their party’s 2008 platform, which said, “Jerusalem is and will remain the capital of Israel.” The platform also now includes a reference to the “God-given potential” of “working people.”

The platform, as formally adopted last night, made no mention of Jerusalem or God.

A Democratic official said President Barack Obama personally intervened, in an effort to have the platform better reflect his views and maintain consistency with the party’s 2008 positions. The Obama administration has long said the status of Jerusalem is an issue that should be negotiated directly by Israelis and Palestinians, as part of the peace process.

‘A Clarification’

Former Ohio Governor Ted Strickland, chairman of the Democrats’ platform drafting committee, called the additions “a clarification.”

“It’s clarified, I think that’s the important thing,” Strickland told reporters.

Republicans seized on the Democrats’ internal dispute. In an interview this afternoon with Fox News Channel, taped before the platform was amended, Romney said the omission of the word God from the document “suggests a party which is increasingly out of touch with the mainstream of American people.”

“This party is veering further and further away into an extreme wing that Americans don’t recognize,” he said in the interview, conducted at a building supply store in West Lebanon, New Hampshire.

Democrats Complained

Some Democratic officials complained after discovering yesterday that the Jerusalem plank wasn’t in the platform.

“They got a lot of calls from people like me,” New York Representative Eliot Engel, a Democrat, said in an interview at the convention. “I’m glad they saw the error of their ways.”

Still, the move to revise the platform upset some delegates. Robert Miller, 79, a retired university professor from Alma, Wisconsin, said he worried the amendment would inflame tensions in the Middle East.

“It will make the situation worse,” Miller said.

An Arab-American group also criticized the decision, calling it a “clear case of putting pandering above responsible politics.”

“This change is a knee-jerk reaction to baseless accusations from the far-right that the Democratic Party has ‘thrown Israel under the bus,’” the Arab American Institute said in a statement today. “Worse still, the vote was clearly forced through the delegation, despite considerable opposition on the floor.”

Although Republicans stated that Jerusalem should be the capital of Israel in their platform this year, the party in its platform scaled back its support from four years ago.

Republican Shift

In their 2008 platform, Republicans wrote: “We support Jerusalem as the undivided capital of Israel and moving the American embassy to that undivided capital of Israel.”

This year’s platform, adopted at the Republican National Convention last week in Tampa, Florida, said the party supports “Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state with secure, defensible borders; and we envision two democratic states -- Israel with Jerusalem as its capital and Palestine -- living in peace and security.”

Many Republican and Democratic leaders have called for Jerusalem to be the undivided capital of Israel, and they frequently promise to move the U.S. embassy to there from Tel Aviv -- a pledge that plays well with many Jewish voters in swing states such as Florida and Ohio.

The vow is almost entirely about domestic politics: Once in office, politicians have done little to enforce the policy, largely because it would undermine attempts to forge a peace deal in the region. Palestinians would like to locate the capital of a future state in East Jerusalem, dividing the city with Jewish leaders.

Embassy Waiver

Then-candidate George W. Bush declared in a 2000 speech before the American Israel Public Affairs Committee that he would move the U.S. embassy “as soon as” he took office. Six months after becoming president, he signed a waiver putting off the move -- a decision he reauthorized for the rest of his presidency.

Obama, too, called for Jerusalem to remain the undivided capital four years ago, in a speech before the American Israel Public Affairs Committee.

While Jewish voters overwhelmingly backed Obama four years ago, support for him among them has softened, according to some polls, amid concerns that the administration is being too tough on Israel and reports of a tense relationship between Obama and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Romney included a stop in Israel during a trip overseas in July and met with Netanyahu, a longtime friend.

Romney’s campaign doesn’t expect to win a majority of Jewish votes, though it sees an opportunity to gain enough to change the outcome in a few swing states.

To contact the reporter on this story: Lisa Lerer in Charlotte, North Carolina at; Jonathan D. Salant in Charlotte, North Carolina at 1832 or;

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Jeanne Cummings at

The Good Business Issue
blog comments powered by Disqus