Bloomberg News

Korea, U.S. Pledge to End Dispute Over Refrigerators

November 30, 2007

South Korea and the U.S. agreed to work together to resolve a dispute between Whirlpool Corp. (WHR:US) and Korean manufacturers over how refrigerators are tested, giving a potential boost to a pending trade accord.

The two countries exchanged letters this week in which Korea pledged to work out a new testing system, the U.S. trade office said. Whirlpool objected that Korea's tests gave an unfair advantage to Korean companies such as LG Electronics Inc. (066570) and Samsung Group. South Korea agreed to scrap the standard earlier this week.

The dispute has taken on heightened importance as lawmakers such as Michigan Democratic Representative Sander Levin have criticized the Korean-U.S. free-trade agreement, saying a variety of South Korean regulations establish unfair trade barriers to American exports to that country.

``With these provisions, and with the KORUS free-trade agreement, it will help ensure a level playing field for American manufacturers,'' Stephen Norton, a spokesman for the U.S. Trade Representative's office, said today.

The Bush administration and South Korea reached an accord earlier this year to eliminate tariffs and curb barriers to investment, the largest such trade pact by the U.S. since the North American Free Trade Agreement in 1993. Trade between the U.S. and South Korea would increase by $18 billion a year, or 23 percent, if the deal goes through, according to an independent U.S. government assessment.

No Vote Scheduled

Congress hasn't scheduled a vote on the accord, as lawmakers object that Korea uses environmental regulations, tax policies and other measures to discriminate against U.S.-made products such as beef and automobiles.

Whirlpool, the world's largest appliance maker, has raised concerns with the U.S. and Korean governments about the testing regime for energy efficiency. It argues that the current system allows Korean-made refrigerators to get lower energy scores, giving them an unfair advantage in the marketplace.

Since the standards went in place in 2003, Whirlpool has seen its share of the Korean market tumble. It sold 25 million refrigerators a year there in 1996 and 2 million last year.

``We look forward to actively participating in the process of adoption and implementation of the new Korean refrigerator energy test procedure,'' said Tom Catania, vice president for government relations at Whirlpool.

Advocates for the free-trade deal said that resolution of this dispute, which could come in April, may help pave the way for Congress to approve the agreement.

Formerly `Antagonistic'

Whirlpool is based in Benton Harbor, Michigan, the home state of Levin, chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee's trade subcommittee and a leading critic of the pact.

``If you look over the last couple of years, the relationship between the countries has gone from an antagonistic one to one where issues are addressed and dealt with,'' said Troy Stangarone, director of congressional affairs at the Korea Economic Institute in Washington and a supporter of the agreement.

Levin said today's announcement leaves other problems unresolved.

``This development relates to only one of the many non- tariff barriers that Korea uses to shut U.S. manufacturers, farmers and service providers out,'' Levin said in a statement. ``Many of us in Congress have called on'' the Bush administration ``to address these issues in the text of the FTA, and until that is done, the Korean FTA remains unacceptable.''

To contact the reporter on this story: Mark Drajem in Washington at

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Michael Forsythe at

Toyota's Hydrogen Man

Companies Mentioned

  • WHR
    (Whirlpool Corp)
    • $189.73 USD
    • -0.79
    • -0.42%
Market data is delayed at least 15 minutes.
blog comments powered by Disqus