The Next Bailout Battle

Posted by: Matthew Goldstein on February 06

Much of the debate in the bank bailout battle has focused on helping the banks rid themselves of securities backed by ailing home loans—many in the last stage of foreclosure. But it’s becoming increasingly clear that bonds backed by commercial real estate loans will pose as great of a threat to the stability of the financial system.

The news that Moody’s Investors Service is reviewing the ratings on some $300 billion in bonds backed by commercial real estate mortgages is another body blow to the nation’s banks. A potential downgrade on so-called commercial mortgage backed securities would lead to a new round of write-downs and losses at the banks. And that, in turn, would likely mean many banks would have to go back to the federal government for another round of bail-out money.

But the decision by Moody’s to take a hard look at CMBS ratings should come as no surprise. The commercial real estate sector has been in a freefall for months now, with defaults and deliquencies on the rise as the recession worsens. Securities backed by loans on retail strip malls have been particularly vulnerable with so many retailers closing their doors.

Also worriesome are all those outstanding construction loans that banks made during the boom years. There’s also concern about loans to property managers that are backed by provisions that included escalating rent clauses. Right now, rents are going down, not up.

A good deal of the $15 billion in losses that Merrill Lynch incurred in the fourth-quarter involved write-downs and losses on commercial real estate-backed securities. The big losses at Merrill forced the federal government to put together a hastily arranged $138 billion bailout package to enable Bank of America to complete the acquision of the brokerage.

The failout from the plunge in commercial property values can be seen at Goldman Sachs. In the firm’s 2008 annual report, the value of hard-to-value Level 3 assets declined by 2% to $66 billion from the prior year. But the decline may have been greater, if not for problems in the commercial property sector. Goldman notes that the drop in Level 3 assets “were partially offset” by a rise the number of “loans and securities backed by commercial real estate due to reduced price transparency.”

Reduced price transparency is another way of saying that Goldman simply can’t put a value on some of its commercial property related assets. Given the way the economy is falling off a cliff, that lack of price transparency in commercial real estate assets is likely to worsen. And none of that is good new for the banks, or the prospects of an economic turnaround.

Reader Comments

Jose Roncal

February 6, 2009 02:41 PM

Major construction projects across the country are on hold. From churches where the membership is uncertain about spending funds, to universities that have seen their endowments collapse, to individual developers who aren’t willing to spend money in the current economic mess. Even architectural firms are feeling the pinch as skittish clients cancel large projects.

Many in the construction industry are pushing Congress to approve President Obama's proposed stimulus plan to revive the economy and pour hundreds of billions of dollars into rebuilding the infrastructure. It could be enough to keep developers, construction workers, architects, engineers, heavy equipment manufactures and staff members employed and supplied with spending cash until the economy recovers.

But will Obama’s plan succeed in reviving the economy and boosting consumer confidence? Will he make good on his promise to spend those funds on rebuilding the country’s infrastructure? Will he even mange to get the necessary funds in the face of growing skepticism over missing money that banks received in the first stage of the bailout package? If things go according to plan, construction firms might be able to turn their attention to public works projects like bridges, roads and schools. When you consider the huge budget shortfalls of many states and municipalities, there appears to be a sizable backlog of projects in need of funding.

This comment was posted by Jose Roncal, co-author of "The Big Gamble: Are You Investing or Speculating?" - For more information, visit www.financialspeculation.com

Thank you for your interest. This blog is no longer active.

 

About

BusinessWeek's Adrienne Carter, Jessica Silver-Greenberg, and David Henry deconstruct the mysteries of high finance, Wall Street, and hedge funds for pros and ordinary investors. E-mail them directly if you've got tips about big deals, a hedge fund, or even securities industry gossip.

BW Mall - Sponsored Links

Buy a link now!