PENSIONS: Work Till You Drop – If You Have A Job

Posted by: Howard Silverblatt on June 4, 2009

The full S&P 500 Pension and OPEB report, including a full listing of issues and data is available at our web site.

I’ll start with the bottom line – pensions are severely underfunded and they aren’t getting better fast. Last year the S&P 500 was $63 billion overfunded, with companies making only minor contributions, shrugging off the Q4,’07 3% equity loss and projecting an 8% 2008 pension gain. The reality of the market however was devastation: a 37% loss for 2008 produced a 43% gap between what was expected and what was delivered. Funding went from $63 billion overfunded to $308 billion underfunded – a $372 billion turnaround in just one year. As a group, the S&P 500 went from 4% over funded to 22% underfunded. Only 21 issues were fully funded, with 29 between 90% and full, 54 between 80% and 90%, and 231 falling below the 80% mark. By comparison, at the end of 1999, when the market was 56% higher, 296 issues were fully funded. As 2008 came to an end corporations were faced with the potential of large cash infusions into their pension funds. With their 2009 expectation of low profits and concern over cash flow, they lobbied and received an executive order suspending the phased-in funding requirements from the Pension Reform Act of 2006 for one year. The result was that many companies were not required to shore up their funds after the massive market declines – basically doubling the bet on 2009.

Companies reacted to the decline by pulling money out of equities and into fixed income. The concept was safety, and the result will add some stability to the portfolios, but it will also reduce the overall returns, since over time equities do better than fixed income. Given the change, the slight drop in expected pension returns to 7.95% from last years 8.02% should actually be interpreted as a bullish statement by funds, and appears to imply that they expect a double-digit bounce back in the market. We suspect that there has already been a shift back to equities as the market has moved up, and that portfolios will experience more of a turnover this year.

So where does that leave us going forward – I have three sets of projection for 2009, none to them good. Remember that we are starting from a $308 billion deficit.

At this point in time, given the belief that (i) rates may slightly increase, (ii) that fixed income portfolios are properly positioned not to incur losses due to rate changes, (iii) a more normalized yield curve of utilized maturities and (iv) the hope that equity markets could prosper with a double-digit gain, it remains mathematically difficult to extrapolate an S&P 500 pension fund that will be anywhere near fully funded by year-end 2009. Given that I again expect to see calls for another postponement of scheduled funding in Washington later this year. My current baseline estimate calls for pensions to remain at the current level of funding, ending 2009 at $313 billion underfunded. My optimistic estimate, based on an S&P 500 level of 1100, which is still 25% below 2007’s close and interest rates 50-75 bps higher across utilized maturities, calculates out to a pension improvement, but underfunding remains solidly in the red by $168 billion. My gloomy forecast, based on a return to the March 2009 low of 676, combined with slightly lower interest rates, increases the underfunding to $496 billion – half a trillion dollars.

As Americans live longer, the gap between existing benefits and personal wealth will widen. Directly or indirectly, the U.S. Government is the insurer of last resort, whether it is via the PBGC or as the medical provider via social or entitlement programs. Pensions and OPEB have become engulfed as a social and political issue, with the key questions being coverage, expense and how to pay for it. Eventually, the government, in conjunction with the private sector, will be forced to address the situation and take the necessary painful steps. The concern is that neither the public nor the private sector has shown a tolerance for the pain associated with the type of action needed to address the problem. The longer the situation goes unaddressed or band-aided, the stronger the measures will have to be to solve the situation. In the end, individuals, either as taxpayers or consumers, will need to pay the bill, as well as live with the reduction in benefits and lifestyle.

The full S&P 500 Pension and OPEB report, including a full listing of issues and data is available at our web site.

Reader Comments

dick engstrom

June 6, 2009 11:51 AM

1974 was the year our government tried to set regulations to protect pensions. however, large companies were still allowed to siphon off monies if the pension fund was over valued during the "good times". in the late 90's when the market was exploding the largest profit centers in the dow 30 was pension income. if pesions are to ever be fixed...this must end and companies should be required to set aside a certain amount of earnings for pension funds...and never allow these monies to be taken back by the company.

trh

June 7, 2009 12:41 AM

retirement is going to return to what it was a hundred years ago,grand parents watching the kids instead of 700 dollars a month to the day care.the children taking care of their parents at home.and god help us maybe some moral influence will be the best pay out!

jordi

June 8, 2009 12:45 AM

yes

jay

June 8, 2009 3:18 AM

If it is underfunded, it is better to open the borders for skilled rich immigrants. Look at Canada they will only allow people from third world countries that can speak, write, and speak fluent English. Then they will look in the immigrants bank accounts. They are certain that these immigrants who are healthy and with high savings rate will bring their money to Canada. Who will laugh at the most at this time?

BIGWEEDS

June 13, 2009 12:14 PM

Folks,
It amazes me to no end that the government does not want us to play on-line poker for money but they have signed all of us up for 3 or 4 pyramid games where you become a bigger loser the older you become. Modern medicine has allowed us to live many more years and the government (that group includes your senators and congressmen and women that you keep sending back to D.C. decade after decade) has made it possible that you will become poorer and poorer as you age. Ain't life wonderful?
Regards

Post a comment

 

About

Bloomberg Businessweek’s Ben Steverman focuses on the latest moves in financial markets and emerging trends in stocks, bonds, and funds, always with an eye toward giving readers a better understanding of the sometimes confusing and often chaotic world of money. Standard & Poor’s senior index analyst Howard Silverblatt will also provide his take on companies’ finances and the markets. Voted one of the “Top 100 Finance Blogs” in 2007.

BW Mall - Sponsored Links

Buy a link now!