Regarding 'Today's Dishonest Attack On The Times': Ex WSJ-er And Current NYT-er Fires Back at WSJ Editorial Page
Posted by: Jon Fine on June 30, 2006
(Gardiner Harris, who sent the following email in response to this bizarre, inflammatory and very lengthy editorial in today’s Wall Street Journal, spent a few years at the Journal before moving to the New York Times in 2003.)
From: Gardiner Harris
Sent: Friday, June 30, 2006 12:53 PM
To: [redacted, but to several top staffers at the Journal, including managing editor Paul Steiger, senior deputy managing editor Daniel Hertzberg, deputy managing editor Marcus Brauchli, DC bureau chief Gerald Seib, Dow Jones Newswires president Paul Ingrassia,and editorial page editor Paul Gigot]
Subject: Shame on the 9th floor
I thought the Wall Street Journal’s editorial page had reached a new low last week when Holman Jenkins Jr. rationalized back-dated stock-option grants. Secretly shoveling shareholder money to top executives and then lying about the practice to shareholders and the government is entirely appropriate, Mr. Jenkins opined. Thank God the Journal’s news division, in a series of important and penetrating stories, reached a different conclusion.
Then came today’s dishonest attack on the Times. While the editorial took pains to distinguish between the Journal’s editorial and news pages, it repeatedly conflated those divisions within the Times. It suggested that the Times’ editorial-page judgments about the Bush Administration, the Iraq war and government leaks drove the news division’s decision to run the Swift story. The Journal’s editorial-page editors know better.
I will leave to others arguments about the merits of the Swift story, whether it could possibly damage the war on terror, and how much credibility editors should give Bush Administration claims about intelligence findings and secrecy needs.
But were I still working for the Journal, I would be insulted that those attacking the Times were failing to curse the Journal in the same foul breath.
The New York Times
1627 I Street NW
Washington DC 20006