Samsung Drops Bid to Buy SanDisk

Posted by: Ihlwan Moon on October 22, 2008

Samsung Electronics on Oct. 22 withdrew its $5.85 billion bid to buy SanDisk, citing a declining value of U.S. memory card maker in the face of a supply glut in the memory chip market. The news came hardly as a surprise as SanDisk sought a higher price while there were no signs its business would improve any time soon after it reported a third quarter loss.

However, the move doesn’t necessarily mean the Korean electronics company has ended its interest in SanDisk. Samsung has a big stake in NAND flash memory chips (used to store data in digital cameras, music players and other portable gadgets) and SanDisk has hundreds of patents in the U.S. and overseas for the chip technologies. Samsung, the No. 1 flash-chip maker with more than 40% market share, pays SanDisk hundreds of millions of dollars annually to license those patents. SanDisk is also the world’s largest supplier of memory cards that use such chips.

Samsung has repeatedly said it will continue to invest multi-billion dollars in memory chips as it sees the current slowdown a chance to expand its presence in an upturn. “I continue to believe that a combination of our two companies would have created a superior global brand, an unparalleled technology platform and the scale and resources to drive convergence in the market place,” Samsung Chief Executive Lee Yoon Woo said in a letter to SanDisk Chairman Eli Harari, notifying the Korean company’s decision to end its six-month bid to acquire the U.S. firm.

Reader Comments

keith ip

October 22, 2008 8:40 AM

It seems Samsung was not considering the huge patent expenses as to believe the deal can be done later with even lower price.
In fact, supply glut in memory chip market is a known fact due to technology improvement, buyer no need to pay unreasonable premium for the highly competing market rather than the concern of economy recession.

huuuuuuuuh!

October 22, 2008 9:19 PM

Lost opportunity for SanDisk share holders. The price SamSung offered will never come back. SanDisk will follow Yahoo's path. SamSung might say "we dodged the bullet!".

WPak

October 23, 2008 8:34 AM

I am surprised and somewhat shocked at the amount Samsung pays to SanDisk for its patents. I knew Samsung paid Qualcomm for its mobile phone technologies. But I did not know Samsung also paid royalties for the memory chips as well. I have praised Samsung for its successes but the question remains: Is Samsung truly an innovator or trendsetter? From what I've read and know about Samsung, my theory is that it will take some time for Samsung to reap benefits from its own patents. If Samsung is paying hundreds of millions copious for patents, Is Samsung just an assembly-line? I admire Samsung's efforts in acquiring SanDisk, which I believe is a smart move in this age of globalization and covergence. I think SanDisk should have considered Samsung's offer, since Samsung is the world's #1 memory chipmaker.

Post a comment

 

About

Bloomberg Businessweek’s team of Asia reporters brings you the latest insights on business, politics, technology and culture from some of the world’s biggest and fastest-growing economies.

BW Mall - Sponsored Links

Buy a link now!