Bloomberg Anywhere Remote Login Bloomberg Terminal Demo Request


Connecting decision makers to a dynamic network of information, people and ideas, Bloomberg quickly and accurately delivers business and financial information, news and insight around the world.


Financial Products

Enterprise Products


Customer Support

  • Americas

    +1 212 318 2000

  • Europe, Middle East, & Africa

    +44 20 7330 7500

  • Asia Pacific

    +65 6212 1000


Industry Products

Media Services

Follow Us

Bloomberg Customers

Townships vs. Naxalism: which India will win?

Posted by: Manjeet Krpalani on May 9, 2008

About 11 years ago, a dynamic and thoughtful scion of a major Indian industrialial house, told me this. He worried, he said, about the divide in India. He worried that there would be bubbles of growth and modernity in India, but not everyone would be able to participate in it. “India will be like a scene from a Jetson’s comic, with one part of the country living in growth bubbles high above the ground, while below will be the teeming masses, hungry and seething that they are not part of that growth.”
It was a frightening picture - more so, because it felt so much like the reality.
A decade has passed, and India has progressed. But with such little reform, and nearly half the country not having had the chance to ride on the growth rocket, is the industrialists’ worst fear coming true?
It has been feeling so these days.

Last month, I was wandering through Gadchiroli, a district in Maharashtra where the militant Naxalites rule and the writ of the state does not run. A few months earlier, while in Orissa, a state in the east, an ancient culture rich in mineral resources, it was evident that the poor are seeing their way of life destroyed by a careless state that's sold mineral access to corporations for sizeable sums. The politicians who approve those deals live like the super-rich, and abdicate all responsibility for their constituents. The environment is being devastated, the land is being raped, the people are protesting and sometimes dying and turning to anyone who will help them. That is a reality of India.
But today I collided with another Indian reality. As I walked through the neat aisles of the Haiko supermarket in Powai, a Bombay suburb, for about four minutes I thought I was in suburban America. There was everything that a suburban American supermarket carries - varieties of biscuits, cheeses, rice, wheat, shampoos, a rack of nice coffee mugs, even non-stick utensils and kitchen towels. Around me were young people - all young people - with push carts piled with their weekend shopping. They knew what to pick, and where to get it. Paid at the counter, took their bags, and sauntered across the road to the Kentucky Fried Chicken, perhaps to the cinema complex, mobile phones at their ears.
This is also India.
These young people have never really known another kind of shopping, I thought in wonder. They've never haggled with the vegetable-wallah in a dirty city steet, or had to pick up and smell fruit and feel the flesh to tell whether it was ripe or sweet or go to another part of town to buy utensils. The supermarket does it all for them. They've all had an education (including the boys at the check-out counter at Haiko), and they're all earning a decent living. They can all hope for a better life.
Haiko is part of an amazing township called Hiranandani Gardens. It was perhaps the first one built in Bombay's environs, by an enterprising doctor's son called Niranjan Hiranandani. It used to be middle class a decade ago - too far from south Bombay, where the financial district was, and where all the action was. But now it's even upper-middle class, with apartments selling at a pricey $500 a square foot - a third to half the price of south Bombay, but pricey still.
In these apartments live the young professionals of the new India - the call centre chiefs, the young doctors, the young MBA-educated managers, the IIT grads who have become entrepreneurs. Hiranandani's Powai offers everything - space for headquarters for multinationals (Colgate Palmolive, for example), posh call centre and back office space (check out the Olympia building), incubation centres (IIT-Bombay is a stone's throw from the township), educational institutes (a new business school focusing on finance), hospitals (the ultra-modern Dr. L.H. Hiranandani Hospital with bright, Western educated and trained Indian returnee doctors). Vijay D. Shetty, the 39-year old orthopedic there who trained at the Wellington Hospital in London before returning home to India, says many many of his peers are coming back to work.
Modern townships like Hiranandani are popping up all over India. The big builders like DLF and Hiranandani and Raheja and Unitech are driving this. So is the government's SEZ plans. As these develop, there will be pockets of super-development across the county, which will look in parts like Singapore or Hong Kong or Sydney or London or Seattle.
The question is, will they link up together, and create a new India without any gaps in the middle?
Or will they result in an India with bubbles of development, high above the seething, Naxal-inspired masses below, an India awaiting catastrophe?

Reader Comments

Jalal Alamgir

May 12, 2008 5:44 PM

Both will continue to happen together - discontent in the masses and young Hiranandani residents. The results of some of that gulf will probably not be pleasant, and some of it will likely be seen in the upcoming elections. It's not that the central government will roll-back pro-globalization policies, but that violent backlash against new wealth and widening inequality will plague state governments.

Jalal Alamgir


May 13, 2008 10:21 AM

It all takes few suicide bombs to destroy the new growth, when the growth is so uneven. It is tragic after 11 5-year plans, India is the home of 25% poorest people of the world and 50% of the population is illiterate. Rural Indians can't organize like urban Indians, and the policy makers cleverly made all the decisions to help urban popoulation. Since Aryan invasion of India 3,000 years ago, they introduced this discrimination in the name varna system and now the same mindset has manifested into rural/urban divide.

shirish kokatay

May 15, 2008 2:39 PM

The description of the two Indias sound similar to how New York looked and smelled during the early decades of the twentieth century - Pockets of wealth surrounded by tenements. The ghettos were filled by newly arrived immigrants who worked in sweat shops and were happy to escape the hopelessness of their countries or origin.
Ultimately economic progress and expansion will lift all boats and offer the new generation of Indians vastly greater opportunities than their parents. No one can stop this trajectory of progress other than a top heavy, socialist, bureaucratic, high taxing Government


May 16, 2008 12:31 AM

Just like manjeet, i was travelling too across villages in south indian states. Prosperity has seeped down that level as well 3-4decades back these very areas i remember to be poor, teeming with beggars, with state buses being the only mode of transprt. today the people are well off. 2 wheelers throng the roads, supermarkets and malls are everywhere infact bigger than the ones in Mumbai. People can communicate in english, mobiles are widely prevalent. The other thing that struck you is that there were no beggars!
It may not have been government driven but the enterprise and drive of the ordinary indian has helped pull the prosperity levels up.
Yes there still would be some states and districts in abysmal condition but its not that prosperity is restricted to the well heeled metro-types

Post a comment



Bloomberg Businessweek’s team of Asia reporters brings you the latest insights on business, politics, technology and culture from some of the world’s biggest and fastest-growing economies.

BW Mall - Sponsored Links

Buy a link now!