Posted by: Lauren Young on April 17, 2009
Are you friends with your kids or kids you know on Facebook?
Lately there has been a heated discussion about grownups “friending” children on the AskLizRyan group, which has almost 25,000 members. (Ryan is a BusinessWeek columnist, and her listserv is a terrific resource for career advice and leads, by the way.)
My son is only four, so being his Facebook friend isn’t an issue—yet. But I am Facebook friends with several teenage girls who babysit for me, as well as a friend’s 13-year-old daughter. Come to think of it, I’m also friends with some of my cousins who are teenagers, too. However, Xavier, my 16-year-old neighbor, rejected my “friend” request. “I’m not friends with grown-ups,” he says.
AskLizRyan member Phyllis, whose sons are 21 and 17, says neither boy is interested in having her in their social networking lives.
Does it hurt her feelings?
Sure, a little bit. However, they have a right to their privacy (yes—even the 17-year-old) and I think they need to make their own decisions on this. Unless I hear that they are in danger (I have friends who have access to their children’s accounts and will let me know if they are worried), I will not invade their privacy. We all need to feel in control of our lives.
I also like what AskLizRyan member Merlee, the mother of a 15-year-old-girl, has to say about being friends with her daughter and her daughter’s peers on Facebook:
I do not keep close tabs on (my daughter’s) profile, allowing her to be herself, but occasionally I do check it out to make sure all is well, and she isn’t being disrespectful, or irresponsible online. The same rules apply to all of her online activities that apply to her offline social activities……I always stress to my daughter that publishing something on Facebook is as good as putting a poster up at her high school with the same information. You are sharing it with the world, even if only your friends see it. Certain people will pass it on, other post to their profiles or blogs, etc. There really is no such thing as privacy here. This is the main factor to keep in mind when using an Internet forum.
As for parents stalking their children and their children’s friends, that is just creepy also. People need to treat online much the same as they would offline. On the flip side, I do agree that parents of younger children (minors) should keep an eye on their kids’ activities online, if for no other reason than to teach them potential consequences of their actions, and the level of respect and safety that is required online….just as it is offline.
When it comes to my younger Facebook friends, I don’t do a lot of cyber-snooping, despite my aspirations of becoming a spy in my youth. If I did see something alarming, such as photos of my friend’s 13-year-old daughter drinking booze, I think I would let her mom know. Thankfully, I’ve never been in this position yet.
What do you think? Is social networking with today’s youth a “creepy” invasion of their personal space, or is it simply a good way to stay connected?
IMHO it's both. And it fully depends on the offline relationship. I was already on fb when my son joined. He chose to friend me and I accepted. Subsequently, some of his friends reached out to me and I declined. I know these kids well and enjoy their company but I no more want to know what they're doing in their teen time than I want them to know what I'm doing in my adult world. And, of course, there's the whole "minor" issue. So, we stay friends "offline". But it's yet another good way to "connect" with my son who knows I may periodically check in with him on fb - but of course would never [heaven forbid] embarrass him by posting to his wall! We keep it simple: blood relation? Good way to stay connected. unrelated? Not for me.
Yes, you should be friends with your children. You should also teach them what is appropriate to post in an open forum and what is not, so even if they are engaging in illicit activities, you'd never know it to look at their facebook page.
I recently joined FB and was the one who showed my son how to set up his page. I left him to it, and later asked if wanted to be my friend. He sent me and invite and his date (somewhat to my surprise) and I only go on his page once and a while). I try to give him his "privacy" here and don't friend his friends. I agree its a good way for me to connect with him a casual kind of way. One time he posted that there were no good pictures of him playing soccer, so I posted for him and he was thrilled.
A lot depends upon how old your kids are and what level of communication you maintain with them.
I know parents who are not "friends" with their kids on Facebook but who have an understanding that the parent can review the account at ANY time and even pull the plug.
There are also kids I know who are not "friends" with their parents online but ARE friends with at least one other related adult (uncle, aunt, etc) who they feel more comfortable sharing. Again the parent can still review but is trusting the child (to an extent).
At the recent MediaSummit many of the speakers commented that their teenage kids would NOT "friend" them on Facebook.
Just last weekend my teenage cousin asked if I was on FB and if I would be her "friend." That meant a lot as she was reaching out to ME.
I'll be honest: I helped my mom set up her Facebook account when she mentioned that all of her friends were registered, but I did so on the condition that she understand I would not friend her.
It sounds harsh, but I am also 23 and entitled to my own privacy. I also have a lot of my relatives as Facebook friends, so if something were horribly wrong then she would find out, but I have made it clear that I neither am involved in any wrongdoing nor do I have anything to hide. And while it may sound odd that I am friends with other relatives - some older than she is - it is also different when it is your own parent who is keeping tabs on every aspect of your life.
I explained to my mom that since I live with her, there is very little about my life that she is unaware of, so my social networking is perhaps my only real private outlet; and, like I said, it's not all that private. I have almost 1100 friends.
I do think that if I was a minor, it would make more sense for her to be my friend. Believe it or not, when that was the case just six years ago, there was no Facebook; at the time, it was in its early stages and was strictly limited to people in select U.S. colleges.
But yes, for minors I think it is a smart move, because with growing technology and more and more dangers due to the new digital world we live in, I don't think it's highly unreasonable to lightly monitor your child's online activities.
If you befriend your child and also post your date of birth, then someone who wants to steal your child's identity has access to his Mother's Date of Birth. So if you befriend your child, it creates identity theft risks if post your true birthday.
For the same reason, consider not posting you maiden name.
When my mom got FB, I was 20, old enough to make my own choices re booze and for my mother to know I was doing so, even if we never talked about it. I was in college, she could have guessed what was going on and tacitly approved it. So I never thought twice about letting her see pictures or conversations with friends. I accepted her friend request.
My sister was 15 and a pretty good kid, but whatever she was doing was done b sneaking around. She was also at an age where sneaking/hiding things from parents is a badge of coolness on its own terms. She rejected mom's friend request.
My guess is the cutoff age for parent-child friendships comes about age 19, 1 year into college. I think that is about when you lose the knee-jerk reaction to being friendly with "grownups," and also when parents come to acknowledge they no longer have complete authority over you.
YES
My daughter is to young to FB, but I was a youth pastor for awhile and used a myspace page soley dedicated to the youth group kids. It was a way they could ask questions about things in there own way and I used to blog events we all did. I found it enriching for all of us, because as a youth group it gave them a place to talk to each other and be closer friends and for me, it gave some insight as to the Teen "outside" world they were living in. But mostly other than hello, I didn't delve into their personal lives unless they asked for advice first.
It important to remember though that if you "friend" them in FB, they have access to your personal life too and maybe some adult things shouldn't be shared with kids.
Like any mother who knows her kids password isn't going to check her child's profile religiously...maybe I grew up in a strange home but my mother would be all over that opportunity.
In this blog, BusinessWeek’s Cathy Arnst, Diane Brady, Anne Newman, Mauro Vaisman, and Lourdes L. Valeriano, lead a broad discussion of the issues and day-to-day concerns of working parents, offering up interviews with work/life experts, examinations of relevant research, and their personal accounts of bouncing between separate, sometimes conflicting worlds.