More news from “the recession ate my homework” front – this involving Southern California real estate and a surprising result. In February I wrote about the growing number of lawsuits in which businesses are arguing that they should be excused from living up to the terms of a deal because of the economic crisis. The current downturn is so severe and unusual, they argue, that it is a “force majeure,” like an earthquake or act of war.
But, I noted, judges generally greet such claims skeptically; usually, a deal is a deal, and a court will enforce it. But a recent ruling brought to my attention was sympathetic to the argument. The case involved a condominium and retail development in Long Beach, Calif. The loan agreement on the project allowed the lender to foreclose on the property if a certain number of condos were not sold at minimum prices. In fact, no units were sold, and the lender, Pacific CityHome, began foreclosure proceedings. In an arbitration proceeding, the developer, Gateway & 4th, argued that the current economic environment made it impossible to sell units at the prices required, and asked for an order halting the foreclosure. Like others in similar proceedings, Gateway invoked the words of former Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan, who told Congress last October that the country was experiencing a “once-in-a-century credit tsunami.” In an April 24 ruling, the arbitrator agreed and enjoined the foreclosure.
The Los Angeles Daily Journal quoted Gateway’s attorney Louis R. (Skip) Miller on the significance of the case. “Usually if the market changes, that’s life, that’s too bad,” he said. “Before, [developers] had no defense against a technical default. Not anymore. Because of the severity of this downturn, they do have recourse.”
How can you manage smarter? Bloomberg Businessweek contributors synthesize insights from the brightest business thinkers, critique the latest management trends, and comment on leaders in the news.