Study: CEOs with MBAs Deliver So-So Performance

Posted by: Louis Lavelle on September 16, 2010

Do MBAs make better CEOs? When a team of researchers from INSEAD posed this question last year, the answer they arrived at was a resounding yes! CEOs with the degree delivered better long-term shareholder value than those without one. Now comes some new research that calls that conclusion into question.

Researchers Sanjai Bhagat, University of Colorado at Boulder; Brian Bolton, University of New Hampshire; and Ajay Subramanian, Georgia State University, found that “hiring new CEOs with MBA degrees leads to short-term improvements in operating performance. We, however, do not find a significant systematic relationship between CEO education and long-term firm performance. CEO education does not seem to be an appropriate proxy for CEO ability.”

The study examined 1,500 companies from 1992 to 2007 and used several performance metrics including return on assets and stock returns. Among the CEOs for whom educational information was available, about 39 percent had MBAs, and of that group, 63 percent attended a “top 20” program. While MBAs overall did little to improve firm performance, the researchers found a “weak positive relationship” between CEOs with MBAs from top schools and company operating performance. So which school you attend does matter, just not a whole lot as far as your company is concerned.

As interesting as that is, the researchers also found something that had them scratching their collective heads. While a CEO's MBA had little or no impact on their company's long-term performance, it was a key factor in whether the CEO was hired in the first place. Even when a CEO with an MBA is fired, the researchers found that companies tend to hire another MBA to replace him. That's not a typo. From the study:

"These results suggest that CEO education does not play a distinguishing role in determining a CEO's ability related to enhancing firm performance. It is certainly possible that the CEO's education does have a critical influence in determining whether or not the individual becomes a CEO (or, even earlier, whether or not the individual gets hired into positions that may lead to becoming a CEO). Nevertheless, it is still rather puzzling (at least to us) that education affects CEO hiring decisions even though it has little effect on long-term firm performance."

The researchers aren't the only ones that are baffled by that finding. I'm a little dumbfounded too. Even if you view the MBA as some kind of good housekeeping seal of approval, if it does nothing for company performance, as the new research suggests, why would corporate boards keep hiring them?

Reader Comments

Aaron Barnes

September 17, 2010 12:15 PM

It gives them a sense of security, false as it seems to be, that the more educated you are the better job you can do. As with experience however, having experience dose not mean you learned anything from it. You may have continued executing a failed model, doomed before the new MBA shows up. Then again, maybe the board that continues to insist on an MBA for CEO is the problem to begin with?

Alvaro Gonzalez

September 23, 2010 8:34 AM

Great article. The study does highlight that MBA CEOs do provide short term improvement, hence, if a departing CEO, whether MBA or not, is being let go from a company, that organization is immediately looking for leadership that will improve the current state, even if it is short-term. One interesting point, and possibly the topic for further research is the fact that many undergraduates and senior managers are now opting for obtaining a MS or MA in Management with a concentration on finance, HR, PM, etc, as opposed to an MBA. Will does CEOs who get a MS or MA in Management will deliver better performance than MBAs?

dan1234

September 23, 2010 1:15 PM

After reading this article I can't help but post this comment about my website that solves the college recruiting problem for students and employers and allows students from all over the world to prove that they are just as smart and hard working as any other student. www.NoodleStorm.com is a website where organizations can submit problems of any type (e.g. business, nonprofit, engineering, computer science, etc.) for college students to solve. The organizations can receive multiple solutions from students all over the world and then whittle through those solutions and pick the top candidates to come in for an interview. This will save organizations many thousands of dollars in recruiting costs and it gives every college student the opportunity to compete for top jobs. Students and professors from most of the top schools in the U.S. and from several international schools are signed up and organizations are submitting problems. Thanks everyone for allowing me to post this unabashedly self-serving comment.

Joey

October 7, 2010 3:30 AM


Why do Boards keep on hiring MBA's? Because those in the board have MBA's. I'd like to see a study that correlates board member MBA numbers to corporate productivity.

The leading hedgefunds have already figured out what MBA's are good for. Hedgefunds now only hire PhDs in the sciences.

Post a comment

 

About

Read daily reports from BusinessWeek editors and reporters Louis Lavelle, Geoff Gloeckler, Alison Damast and Francesca Di Meglio and boost your chances of getting into your best-fit B-school.

BW Mall - Sponsored Links

Buy a link now!