Already a Bloomberg.com user?
Sign in with the same account.
On the outskirts of Yinchuan, a sleepy provincial capital near the Gobi Desert, workers put the finishing touches on Château Changyu Moser XV, a vast building with white stone walls and black-tiled mansard and domed roofs. If it weren’t for the cast-metal statues of Chinese lions guarding the main gate, it could pass as a classical château found in the cradle of France’s Loire Valley. When it opens soon, the 150-acre estate will serve as local headquarters for Changyu Pioneer Wine, a Chinese vintner that already has ersatz châteaux in other parts of China. This summer the company announced plans to spend $950 million on a “wine city” in eastern China’s Shandong province, complete with two châteaux and a European-style village.
Photograph by Xinhua/Eyevine/Redux
As the country’s nouveau riche continue to spend lavishly on wine, such copycat French castles—as well as Mission-style Napa Valley knockoffs—are rising out of the countryside. In some places winemakers don’t even bother with a vineyard—they just have a castle with a cellar full of trucked-in wines. “I almost don’t care about how good the wine is,” says Chinese architect and winemaker Qingyun Ma. “As soon as I see a fake French château, I think there’s something wrong.”
Ye Rin Mok for Bloomberg Businessweek
Ma, 47, is one of the growing number of Chinese oenophiles who want the wine world to look beyond hyperreal European settings and start thinking of made-in-China cabernet sauvignon or pinot noir without laughing. That’s not easy, since the country has no winemaking tradition of its own. In China, people who wanted a drink traditionally downed shots of baijiu—fierce, clear booze made from sorghum that remains a staple at Chinese banquets. When they tried to make wine, the product was barely drinkable. Shao Xuedong, chief winemaker at Cofco Junding Winery, a state-owned company that operates a Napa-inspired winery in Shandong, remembers when he first started in the business in the 1990s. Back then, “at least 95 percent” of Chinese wine wasn’t real, he says. “It was just some blend of water, sugar, and grape juice.”
Emma Gao, 36, is the winemaker at Silver Heights, a family winery in Yinchuan that produces some of China’s most admired vintages. Gao, who studied at La Faculté d’Oenologie de Bordeaux, says many of her neighbors don’t understand what she’s trying to accomplish. “Here, people think a good wine shouldn’t give you a headache the next morning,” she says.
Even so, Gao and other serious vintners see huge potential. Chinese bought 156 million cases in 2011, making the country the world’s fifth-largest wine market, and purchases should hit 250 million by 2016, according to London-based market research group International Wine & Spirit Research. “Before, people would just buy wine to show off, but that’s changing,” says Shaun Rein, managing director of China Market Research Group in Shanghai. “Younger Chinese are drinking it at home.”
Given the poor track record of native wines, it’s not surprising that Chinese first looked abroad. Buyers from China have become major investors in Bordeaux. The official China Daily newspaper estimated in August that Chinese have purchased at least 25 estates in the past year. China is also the world’s biggest importer of Bordeaux wines, accounting for 35 percent of that region’s exports. California wines are popular, too. After retiring from the Houston Rockets, Chinese basketball star Yao Ming launched Yao Family Wines in November. The company produces a cabernet sauvignon in Napa Valley, with French beverage maker Pernod Ricard (RI) distributing it in China.
The emphasis may be on imports, but local wine is improving. More Chinese are going overseas to study winemaking, and critics have noticed: A cabernet red blend by Helan Qingxue, a winery in Yinchuan, last year won the “Best Red Bordeaux Varietal Over £10 International Trophy” at the Decanter World Wine Awards.
Photograph by ChinaFotoPress/Getty Images
China’s boutique winemakers hope the plaudits will attract more experts to China to nurture its winemaking culture. France’s Castel Group and Rémy Cointreau (RCO) have both teamed up with Chinese winemakers. Perhaps the biggest name in Bordeaux, Domaines Barons de Rothschild (Lafite), has staked its flag in China, with vines planted and a winery under construction in Shandong. Working with state-owned local partner Citic, the famed French winemaker had a groundbreaking ceremony in March for the 4.3-acre winery. Overseeing the project is General Manager Gerard Colin, a Frenchman with more than 50 years of wine-producing experience who has lived in China since 1997. “I think we can make a wine with balance and complexity,” he says.
Before teaming up with the Rothschilds, Colin helped out a winery just down the road called Treaty Port. At the center of its 52 acres is an imitation 17th century Scottish castle, a stone fortress complete with a Union Jack flying on the flagpole at the top. Finished in 2009, the castle has six bedrooms and a large wood-paneled hall. Don’t expect any European gimmicks from Lafite’s first Chinese operation, however. Colin vows no cheesy castle this time. “We are in China,” he explains. “We don’t do Versailles.”
That’s what Ma likes to hear. Ma splits his time between Shanghai and Los Angeles, where he’s dean of the architecture school at the University of Southern California. He operates a winery and resort near his hometown of Xi’an, in central China, and he’s adding three new buildings, all of them inspired by the simple brick homes of the nearby villages. He’s started a wine-themed feed on Sina Weibo, China’s answer to Twitter, and his company sponsors wine-tasting teams at Chinese universities.
Ma has also launched a consulting business. One client, Star China Investment & Development, hopes to develop a winery and resort in Fangshan, near Beijing, without imitating winemakers from overseas. “Wine is not necessarily something American, French, or Australian,” says Han Yanchang, Star China’s deputy general manager. “It’s also something Chinese.” What sort of building does Han have in mind? “I think it must have a Chinese flavor or style,” he says quickly. “If it doesn’t, then Professor Ma will criticize us.”
Changyu spokesman Gu Dezhou says there’s good reason to build faux châteaux. “Wines are from the West,” he says in an e-mail. “We use this style to show the culture.” Ma isn’t convinced. Peering though the Yinchuan château’s front gate, he can’t contain his anger. “I hate it,” he says. “This place is a serious joke.” Down the street from the castle is a Changyu office building with fake wine barrels as part of its façade. “Kitsch,” Ma says with a sigh. “Kitsch to its maximum vulgarity.”