Stock Info for the Masses sells research to the little guy--and is making money

Photo by Shonna Valeska
Karaev has stayed ahead of investors' changing demands
When debuted in November, 1998, it represented everything the Internet revolution was supposed to be about: Giving the little guy access to information once hoarded by the big shots.

Suddenly, small investors could log on and get thousands of stock research reports from big-name brokerage houses like Merrill Lynch ( MER), J.P. Morgan ( JPM), and Bear Stearns ( BSC). Until then, these data-rich reports had been sealed behind big oaken doors, spirited only to professional money managers and the wealthiest individual investors.

Soon, more than 100,000 people a month were registering to use, one of a family of Web sites operated by New York-based ( MLTX). And in October, unveiled what many Net companies may never see: a profit. It earned $210,000 on sales of $22.8 million in its third quarter. ''This proves our business model works,'' beams Isaak Karaev, chairman and founder of

Clearly, not all dot-coms are dot-bombs. What's story shows is that survival on the Web depends on the right formula: a unique product, a diverse stream of customers, and a low-cost way of reaching them. has it all. It gets its research from brokerage firms for free in exchange for information about customers and a cut of sales. then sells research to small investors on a per report basis and to professional money managers through yearly subscriptions. It also designs Web sites for brokerage houses. Sponsorships and banner advertising--the major revenue sources for many Web companies--make up just 19% of's sales. ''Our success lies in being able to package research in different ways,'' Karaev says.

Still, a small profit doesn't guarantee that will grow to be a big company. It is in a constant fight with more established rivals like First Call Corp. and Zacks Investment Research Inc. Then there's the possibility that brokerage firms will bring their research distribution in-house, eliminating the need for third-party players. And if the stock market continues to wobble or falls further, consumers may lose interest in research entirely. Despite the recent quarter's profit, will finish this year in the red. As Wall Street continues to punish dot-coms,'s shares have dropped 82% in the last 18 months, from $65 in April, 1999, to $12 today.

So far, Karaev has proved adept at navigating the changing demands of investors. When he founded Multex in April of 1993, Karaev, a computer programmer at Automatic Data Processing Inc.'s financial information division, was looking for a better way to electronically deliver research from brokerage firms to money managers. The leader in the business was First Call, a division of publisher Thomson Corp. But First Call's transmissions were just a few paragraphs, and it operated a closed system that required a dedicated server and special computers at each customer's site.

After Karaev raised $7 million from venture capitalists, he developed software that transmitted research directly to a client's PC. First Call launched a competing product, but Karaev--working with a smaller staff and budget--charged a few hundred dollars a year, while First Call's rates remained in the thousands of dollars. When the Web took off three years later, Karaev revamped his product so money managers could access reports via the Net. He changed the name to and he took the company public in March of 1999.

By racing to the Web, was able to provide an alternative to First Call that would-be rivals found hard to duplicate. Today Multex provides 2 million reports from 750 brokerages and research houses. And has been quick to launch new businesses. As Karaev called on brokers to convince them to use his service, he discovered they needed someone to design and manage their Web sites. So in 1997 he launched MultexEXPRESS, and pulled in such clients like U.S. Bancorp Piper Jaffray Inc. ( USB) MultexEXPRESS accounts for one third of's sales.

The final leg of Karaev's business is MultexInvestor, which offers stock research to small investors. The reports sell for between $10 and $150 each. Several firms, like Merrill Lynch and J.P. Morgan, sponsor the site and use it to lure customers. Users are offered such incentives as free access for a month in return for providing their contact information to brokerages that want to pitch their services.

Still, competitors are gaining fast. First Call and Zacks continue to improve their Web services. First Call's parent, Thomson Corp., has been aggressively buying firms that make portfolio management software and stock analysis tools, in a bid to create a one-stop shop for money managers. ''All Multex does is research,'' says Suresh Kavan, chief executive of Thomson's money manager division. ''We serve the portfolio management company from beginning to end.''

But when investors start searching the dustbin for dot-com stocks with real value, is likely to rise to the top. Chase H&Q analyst Gregory W. Smith expects to earn $26 million next year on revenues of $143 million, up from an estimated loss of $2.1 million on $82 million in sales this year. keeps carving out new markets. In September, seven brokerage houses announced they would partner on, a research and trading portal for institutional money managers. The firms chose to build and run the site. ''They have the best technology,'' says Laurence Tosi, a Merrill Lynch & Co. executive. This coup is more evidence that the investors who knocked the stuffing out of's shares should do a bit more research on this dot-com winner.


_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

EBIZ Cover Image, link to ebiz table of contents
EBIZ Contents for issue dated Nov. 20, 2000

Stock Info for the Masses

TABLE: The Multex Method

ONLINE EXTRA: For Full-Service Brokers, Is "Not the Enemy"

E-Mail to Business Week Online

Copyright 2000-2009, Bloomberg L.P.
Terms of Use   Privacy Notice